Meat & Poultry

Creating the perfect smoked brisket takes skill, patience, and understanding of the smoking process. But smoking a brisket on a pellet grill is not the same as with charcoal, wood, or propane. So here’s how to cook a brisket on a pellet grill.

A pellet grill offers home cooks a convenient way to achieve that beautiful smoke ring and tender meat without constant temperature monitoring.

Whether you’re preparing your first brisket or looking to perfect your technique, the key lies in choosing the right whole packer brisket and maintaining a consistent temperature. A good brisket starts with quality meat from your local grocery store or butcher shop.

The cooking process requires attention to details like trimming the fat cap correctly and monitoring the internal temperature of the meat. While seasoned pitmasters might prefer more traditional Texas methods, pellet grills make it easier for beginners to achieve delicious results.

Let’s explore the step-by-step instructions for smoking a juicy brisket that will impress on any special occasion. holiday, or backyard bbq party. From selecting your meat to achieving that perfect final slice, we’ll cover every important step.

Not sure how much brisket to buy for how many people you have?

In a recent article, I get into not only how much brisket to buy per person, but how much brisket usually is per pound and how much cooked brisket you’ll end up with.

Just click that link to read it on my site.

What Kind of Brisket Should You Buy?

For the best results, look for a whole packer brisket that has good marbling (intramuscular fat). Choose one that’s between 12-16 pounds, with a fat cap about 1/4 inch thick.

Avoid pre-trimmed flat cut briskets from grocery stores, as these often dry out during the long cooking process. Instead, visit a butcher shop where you can inspect the whole brisket’s quality. Look for meat that’s firm and deep red with white (not yellow) fat.

While Wagyu brisket offers amazing marbling, it’s not necessary for your first brisket. A good Choice or Prime grade whole packer brisket will give you excellent results at a more reasonable price.

Want more tips on picking the best brisket possible?

In a recent article, I cover EVERYTHING you need to know about picking the best brisket possible at the grocery store. And I give you the pros and cons of each kind. I even cover if it’s worth paying for Wagyu beef!

Just click that link to read it on my site.

How To Trim a Brisket

To trim a brisket, start with a sharp knife and place your whole brisket on a large cutting board. Remove the hard fat and silver skin from the meat side, as these won’t render during cooking.

Trim the fat cap to about 1/4 inch thickness, removing any excess fat. Pay special attention to where the point and flat connect, removing the thick layer of hard fat between them.

Square up the edges and corners to ensure even cooking. Some pitmasters prefer different trimming methods, but maintaining that thin fat cap while removing hard fat and connective tissue gives you the best results for a juicy, tender brisket.

What Are the Best Wood Pellets For Smoking a Brisket?

Oak pellets create the most traditional smoke flavor, especially for Texas-style brisket. Legendary pitmaster Aaron Franklin uses only oak for his famous briskets at Franklin BBQ in Austin, though he cooks on traditional smokers rather than pellet grills.

On a pellet grill smoker, oak pellets provide consistent heat and clean smoke. You can also experiment with hickory for a stronger smoke flavor or a blend of oak and cherry for a milder, slightly sweet profile.

Avoid mesquite pellets for long cooks as they can make your brisket taste bitter. For the best results, use quality pellets from reputable brands and avoid anything with fillers or oils added.

CLICK HERE to see the best selling Traeger pellets on Amazon

What Rub or Seasonings Are Best for Smoking Brisket?

Traditional Texas-style brisket uses just coarse kosher salt and coarse black pepper in equal parts. This simple dry rub, favored by legendary pitmaster Aaron Franklin, lets the beef and smoke flavors shine.

While I’ve experimented with ingredients like chili powder, brown sugar, paprika, and cumin, I’ve found that the simple salt and pepper approach produces the best brisket. The smoke from your pellet grill adds plenty of flavor without needing additional seasonings.

Apply the rub generously to your trimmed brisket, covering the entire surface. Let it sit at room temperature while your smoker heats up. This basic seasoning creates a delicious bark during the long cooking process.

Not sure how to use a pellet grill?

On my sister site I have the ultimate guide to Traeger pellet grills. Even if you have a different brand, the steps will be virtually identical, so just click that link to read it. I walk you through my first pellet grill and cover everything you need to know.

Should You Cook Brisket With Fat Side Up Or Down on a Pellet Grill?

Fat side down is what you want on a pellet grill.

The location of your pellet grill’s heat source determines whether to cook fat side up or down. While legendary pitmaster Aaron Franklin prefers fat side up when smoking with traditional wood, pellet grills typically heat from below.

For most pellet smokers, cooking fat side down protects the meat from direct heat and prevents the flat cut from drying out. Place the thicker point cut closer to your grill’s heat source, as its extra fat helps insulate that section.

Keep the fat cap trimmed to about 1/4 inch thick regardless of orientation. Remember that on a pellet grill, the rendered fat won’t actually penetrate the meat – it’s mainly about protecting it during the long cooking process.

Should You Spritz a Brisket?

Spritzing your brisket can help create a beautiful smoke ring and prevent the surface from drying out during the long cooking process. Use a spray bottle filled with any combination of beef broth, apple juice, apple cider vinegar, or even plain water starting after the first few hours of smoking.

Spritz the entire brisket every hour or so when you check the internal temperature.

However, don’t spritz too frequently as opening your pellet smoker causes temperature fluctuations. Once you wrap your brisket, whether with pink butcher paper or foil, you can stop spritzing.

Remember that a consistent temperature matters more than frequent spritzing for achieving a tender, juicy brisket.

Wondering how pellet grills compare to wood smokers?

In a recent article, I break down all the differences and pros and cons of both wood smokers and pellet grill smokers, and ultimately come to a conclusion as to which type works best for smoking meats like brisket.

Just click that link to read it on my sister site.

Should You Wrap a Brisket?

Wrapping your brisket helps push through the stall period when the internal temperature hits around 165°F. Pink butcher paper is ideal as it lets the meat breathe while retaining moisture.

Some pitmasters use aluminum foil (the Texas crutch), which speeds up cooking but can soften the bark. If using foil, unwrap for the last hour to firm up the bark. For best results with wrapped brisket, maintain a consistent temperature and keep checking with your meat thermometer.

Whether using paper or foil, wrap tightly when the internal temperature reaches 165°F and the bark is dark and firm. This helps create a tender, juicy brisket.

How Long Does a Brisket Take on a Pellet Grill?

A whole packer brisket typically takes 1-1.5 hours per pound when smoked at 225°F on a pellet grill. A 12-pound brisket usually takes around 12-18 hours for the internal temperature to reach 203°F.

Start checking for tenderness when the internal temperature reaches 195°F. Your meat thermometer should slide in like butter when it’s done. Remember that every brisket cooks differently based on its size, fat content, and ambient temperature.

How Long Should Smoked Brisket Rest Before Slicing?

A long rest is crucial for a juicy brisket. Let your wrapped brisket rest for at least 2 hours, though 3-4 hours is better for a whole packer brisket.

Keep the meat wrapped in pink butcher paper or foil during the rest period. Place it in an empty cooler or warm oven (turned off) to maintain temperature. The internal temperature should slowly drop to around 145°F before slicing.

Never skip the rest period, even if guests are waiting. A properly rested brisket will be more tender and hold its juices better when you slice it on your cutting board.

How to Slice Brisket (the right way)

Look at your rested brisket and notice the direction of the muscle fibers – these are the grain. You’ll spot lines running in a specific direction, like wood grain. The point and flat cuts have grains running in different directions.

First, find where the point and flat meet – there’s usually a thick layer of fat between them. Cut through this seam to separate them completely into two pieces. This makes it easier to slice each section properly.

For the flat cut (the more rectangular piece), slice perpendicular to those muscle fibers, about the width of a pencil. When you get to the point cut (the thicker, more triangular piece), rotate it 90 degrees to slice against its grain. If you’re unsure about grain direction, make a small test cut – if you see long strings of muscle fiber, rotate 90 degrees.

A properly sliced piece should show those muscle fibers running up and down, not lengthwise across your slice.

Do You Reheat a Rested and Sliced Brisket Before Serving?

A properly rested brisket shouldn’t need reheating for immediate serving. If you’ve kept it wrapped and insulated, it should still be warm (around 140-145°F) after a 2-4 hour rest.

However, if your brisket has cooled too much, place slices in a pan with a splash of beef broth. Cover tightly with aluminum foil and warm in a 250°F oven until heated through. Check the meat thermometer for an internal temperature of about 140°F.

Never reheat freshly sliced brisket in a microwave, as this will make your tender meat tough and dry.

Pellet Grill Brisket Mistakes to Avoid

Cooking pellet grill brisket can be tricky, especially for first-time home cooks.

This tough cut of meat requires patience, the right cooking process, and careful attention to detail. Mistakes can turn a potentially delicious brisket into a dry, chewy disappointment. Understanding what to avoid is just as important as knowing what to do.

Here are common mistakes to steer clear of when smoking brisket.

• Skipping proper trimming: Leaving too much fat cap or silver skin on a whole brisket prevents seasoning from penetrating and results in uneven cooking.
• Using too much seasoning: Heavy rubs, especially with brown sugar, can burn during the smoking process, masking the natural smoke flavor of the brisket.
• Opening the grill lid too often: This lets out heat and smoke, disrupting the consistent temperature that’s crucial for a tender, juicy brisket.
• Skipping the rest: Cutting into the brisket immediately after cooking can cause the juices to escape, leaving it dry instead of tender meat.
• Ignoring the temperature probe: Don’t rely on guesswork; use a meat thermometer to ensure the internal temperature reaches 195-205°F for tender results.
• Using marinades or sauces during cooking: Sauces like BBQ sauces or Worcestershire sauce can overpower the natural flavor of the beef and ruin a beautiful smoke ring. If using at all, add them when eating.
• Choosing the wrong wood pellets: Strong woods like mesquite can overpower the flavor, while fruitwoods or oak are better for more traditional Texas-style brisket.

Avoiding these mistakes ensures a flavorful brisket with tender meat and a beautiful smoke ring. Always use a meat thermometer to check the internal temperature of the brisket.

Pairing the right trimming method with a long rest on a cutting board gives the best results. With a pellet smoker and some practice, home cooks can master the art of smoked beef brisket for any special occasion.

Looking for a budget smoker?

In a recent article, I take a look at the 15 best budget smokers under $375. I look at all types including pellet grill smokers, giving you the pros and cons of all of them so you can make the best decision for you.

Just click that link to read it on my sister site.

Final Thoughts

Smoking the perfect brisket on your pellet smoker takes time and patience, but the results are worth the effort. Whether you wrapped your brisket in pink butcher paper or used the Texas crutch with aluminum foil, letting it rest properly is the final important step.

Remember that every cut of meat is different, so use your meat thermometer as a guide but also learn to recognize when the temperature probe slides in like butter. The entire process from trimming the fat cap to slicing your tender meat teaches valuable lessons about smoking techniques.

With these steps and some practice, you’ll master cooking this tough cut of meat. A properly smoked brisket with its beautiful smoke ring and rich flavor makes any special occasion memorable. Just remember: maintain a consistent temperature, trust your instant-read thermometer, and give it that long rest before slicing.

Wondering if the beef is better at Sam’s Club or Costco?

In a recent article, I compare beef quality, flavor, and prices at Sam’s and Costco, the two largest grocery club stores. I even cover if both offer USDA Prime or Wagyu beef.

Just click that link to read it on my site.

Frequently Asked Questions

How to Reheat Brisket the Next Day

The best way to reheat brisket is to wrap slices in aluminum foil with a splash of beef broth. Heat in a 325°F oven until the internal temperature reaches 165°F.

Alternatively, vacuum seal portions immediately after slicing. Reheat sealed bags in 165°F water for about 45 minutes. This method helps the meat stay tender and juicy without drying out.

Never microwave brisket as it will become tough and lose moisture. Always let reheated slices rest for 5-10 minutes before serving.

Tips for the Best Smoked Beef Brisket

• Maintain a consistent temperature around 225°F throughout the long cook
• Use a good instant read thermometer and meat probe – temperature accuracy is crucial
• Don’t rush the trimming process – proper fat cap thickness affects the final result
• Let your rubbed brisket sit at room temperature while the smoker heats up
• Don’t keep opening the pellet smoker to check – this loses heat and extends cooking time
• Wrap in pink butcher paper at 165°F internal temperature
• Let the brisket rest properly before slicing – at least 2 hours for best results
• Always slice against the grain for tender meat

What is the 3/2:1 Rule for Brisket?

The 3/2/1 method divides your cook into three phases. Smoke the unwrapped brisket for 3 hours to develop bark and smoke flavor, then wrap in pink butcher paper for 2 hours to push through the stall.

Finally, unwrap and smoke for 1 more hour to firm up the bark.

However, this timing is just a guide – always cook to internal temperature and base cook estimates on the size of the brisket rather than time. Your wrapped brisket needs to reach 203°F internal temperature for tender meat, regardless of how long it takes.

So essentially, ignore this rule, lol.

How Do You Keep a Brisket Moist in a Pellet Smoker?

Start with a properly marbled whole packer brisket and trim the fat cap to 1/4 inch thickness. Keep a consistent pellet smoker temperature around 225°F and spritz with beef broth every hour after the first few hours.

Wrap in pink butcher paper when the internal temperature hits 165°F. This helps push through the stall while letting the meat breathe. Always let your wrapped brisket rest for at least 2-3 hours after cooking to redistribute juices.

Remember that proper trimming, wrapping, and resting matter more than constant spritzing for a juicy brisket.

---

Middle Class Dad is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. As an Amazon Associate, I may earn a small commission from qualifying purchases if you click to Amazon from my site and choose to make a purchase. This is no way increases the cost to you.

Brisket is considered the best of all the BBQ options. But it’s not cheap, so you don’t want to over-order and end up with way too much. So when you’re budgeting for your next gathering, how much is brisket per pound?

As a general rule, expect to pay between $4-6 per pound for uncooked brisket. Brisket that has been trimmed of excess fat will be more per pound. Also, expect to pay more for USDA Prime or Wagyu.

And how much is ideal per person?

We’ll find out about brisket, how much it’s sold for at Costco and Sam’s, and whether it’s worth it to buy Prime-grade brisket. But we’ll actually look at real-world prices for all types of brisket and look at several cost-saving grocery store hacks you can use to save a lot on your next brisket!

Let’s get into it.

Why Choose Brisket?

Brisket, a staple in BBQ culture, stands out for its rich, savory flavor derived from its fat and collagen. It’s not just about taste; the slow-cooking process of brisket is a satisfying experience, embraced as a tradition by BBQ enthusiasts. Brisket prices vary based on quality and preparation, influenced by marbling and cut.

For cost-conscious shoppers, warehouse clubs like Costco offer brisket at reasonable rates, though not all cheap options guarantee flavor and tenderness. Local butchers provide a range of cuts, often with helpful advice and occasional discounts. The cost is also dependent on weight, making size selection important to avoid leftovers or shortages.

Beyond the initial purchase, brisket’s value extends to the cooking experience and the joy of sharing succulent, flavorful meat. While factors like cost and availability influence buying decisions, the satisfaction of preparing and enjoying a quality brisket makes it a worthy investment for BBQ lovers. With these insights, choosing the right brisket becomes a less daunting task.

How Much Is Brisket? – Pro Tips

Generally, brisket prices can range from around $3 to $8 per pound for a choice grade brisket at a supermarket. However, for prime grade brisket, often sought after for its higher marbling and flavor, prices can range from $5 to $12 per pound.

The price range of $3 to $8 per pound for choice brisket at grocery stores can be attributed to several factors:

1. Regional Variations: The cost of living and local demand for brisket differ across regions, influencing its price. In areas where brisket is a staple in local cuisine, such as in the Southern United States, it might be priced more competitively. Conversely, in regions where brisket is less popular, prices can be higher due to lower turnover and higher transportation costs.
2. Supply and Demand: Fluctuations in supply and demand significantly impact brisket prices. For instance, during peak barbecue seasons, such as summer and major holidays like the 4th of July, demand for brisket increases, often driving up prices. Off-season, prices may drop due to lower demand.
3. Grocery Store Pricing Strategies: Individual grocery stores have different pricing strategies. Some may offer brisket at lower prices as a loss leader to draw customers in, while others might price it higher as part of a premium product range. Large chain stores often have more competitive pricing compared to smaller, independent stores.
4. Quality Variations within the Choice Grade: Even within the USDA’s choice grade, there can be variations in quality. Brisket with higher marbling (intramuscular fat) within the choice category might be priced higher due to its superior flavor and tenderness compared to a leaner choice brisket.
5. Market Conditions and Cost Fluctuations: The price of beef, including brisket, is subject to fluctuations in the agricultural market, affected by factors like feed costs, cattle supply, and even international trade conditions. These broader market dynamics can cause variations in brisket prices at the retail level.

At warehouse clubs like Costco or Sam’s Club, brisket can be more economical, especially when bought in bulk.

Here, you might find prices slightly lower than average supermarkets, hovering around the lower end of the price spectrum. Butcher shops and specialty meat markets, known for premium quality, often price brisket higher, especially for grass-fed or organic varieties.

These can cost upwards of $10 per pound, and for Wagyu brisket, known for exceptional marbling and quality, prices can soar to $20 per pound or more.

Seasonality and regional factors also play a role in brisket pricing. In areas where barbecue is more popular, such as the Southern United States, brisket may be more competitively priced. During barbecue season, typically in the summer months, prices may rise due to increased demand.

Let’s examine all the different options and prices for raw, uncooked brisket:

• USDA Select Whole Packer Brisket – $3.00/lb
• USDA Choice Whole Packer Brisket – $4.00/lb
• Trimmed Flat Brisket – $5.00/lb.
• Trimmed Point Brisket – $6.00/lb.
• USDA Prime Whole Packer Brisket – $4.50/lb
• Grass-Fed Whole Packer Brisket – $5.50/lb
• Wagyu Prime Whole Packer Brisket – $8.25/lb. 

But the price of brisket changes with the season. For example, during summer, when it’s barbecue season, expect a higher price.

Brisket cost may go up by about $0.50 because of increased demand. Interestingly, this is also the time stores usually offer sales. The price could drop below $2, especially at places like Walmart.

Of course, where you are in the country will also impact prices.

Whole-packer brisket tends to cost less than flat-cut brisket, which is sold separately. This is because any part that leads to waste usually attracts higher prices.

How to Find Affordable Brisket

Finding affordable brisket is easier than you might think, especially if you explore warehouse clubs like Costco or Sam’s Club. These clubs often have high-quality brisket at competitive prices, but remember you’re buying in bulk, so ensure ample freezer space or friends to share with. For barbecue enthusiasts, brisket is a coveted choice, yet its price can be daunting. The key to affordability is watching for sales and discounts, particularly around major grilling holidays.

Local butchers are also great for finding brisket at reasonable prices. They offer a range of cuts and can provide insights into the quality and marbling of the meat. Additionally, online meat markets have become a viable option, offering competitive prices on quality brisket with detailed descriptions and photos.

Whether you’re opting for warehouse deals, waiting for sales, or visiting local butchers, being informed and flexible in your shopping approach is essential for finding brisket without breaking the bank. With these strategies, you can enjoy delicious brisket at a value that suits your budget.

1. Join a Warehouse Club – Sam’s or Costco

Joining a warehouse club like Costco or Sam’s Club can lead to significant savings on brisket.

These clubs often offer high-quality brisket at prices lower than supermarkets or local butchers due to their bulk buying, passing savings to customers. This approach is ideal for frequent barbecue hosts or brisket enthusiasts looking for economical purchases.

Warehouse clubs provide various brisket cuts, with clear labeling on packaging, aiding customers in selecting the right cut for their cooking needs, be it slow-roasted dinners or smoked BBQ.

Additionally, these clubs often run sales and discounts, further reducing the average cost of brisket. Joining a warehouse club can be a savvy move for maximizing brisket value, offering affordability without compromising quality. While shopping, consider factors like quality grade and cut to ensure the best value.

As of the time of writing, Costco and Sam’s brisket goes for $5.49 per pound for Choice whole brisket and $11.99 for Prime  flat-cut brisket.

The following is usually what’s on offer at Costco: 

• USDA Choice Commodity Beef Brisket with 18 lb weight on average
• USDA Choice Beef Brisket Flat with 8 lb weight on average
• USDA Prime Commodity Beef Brisket with 14 lb weight on average

2. Check Out Your Local Butcher

For high-quality brisket at great prices, your local butcher is an invaluable resource.

They offer not only affordable options but also expert advice on brisket cuts and selection. Local butchers understand the nuances of different cuts, helping you choose the right one for your culinary needs, whether it’s finding well-marbled brisket or the best cut for a barbecue.

Local butchers often provide sales and discounts competitive with larger stores, benefiting from bulk purchases from trusted suppliers. While warehouse club deals are attractive, local butchers might outdo them, especially when considering membership fees. Shopping at a local butcher also supports small businesses.

Building a relationship with your local butcher can lead to insights on economical brisket purchases, like buying in bulk during sales or choosing less popular cuts that offer similar flavors at lower prices.

They provide quality assurance, ensuring you get value for your purchase. Local butchers can guide you in selecting and cooking brisket, making them a valuable ally for any barbecue plan. Quality and value are paramount, and a local butcher can ensure you get the best of both.

3. Wait for Sales

Brisket prices fluctuate throughout the year. As a savvy shopper, watch for sales and discounts at retail stores, especially during big barbecue holidays like July 4th and Labor Day. This is when stores often reduce brisket prices to attract customers.

Seasonal sales are key, but knowing where to find these deals is crucial. It’s a myth that only local butchers or specialty shops offer sales. Wholesale retailers like Costco and Sam’s Club frequently provide brisket deals due to their bulk purchasing power, offering significant savings.

When evaluating sale prices, assess the quality of the brisket. Look for marbling, as it indicates tenderness and flavor. For large gatherings, consider purchasing a whole packer brisket for cost-effectiveness.

Ultimately, whether brisket is worth the price depends on your budget, occasion, and taste preferences. Quality brisket, even at a higher cost, offers the satisfaction of a delicious, home-cooked meal.

4. Buy a Whole Side of Beef

Buying a whole side of beef, while seemingly excessive, can be an economical strategy for brisket lovers. This bulk purchase offers a constant supply of high-quality brisket and other beef cuts, allowing for a variety of home-cooked meals. It’s like having your own wholesale source, with substantial savings on high-quality cuts.

This approach requires ample freezer space and possibly vacuum-sealing equipment for long-term storage. Considerations like transport and processing fees also play into the cost-effectiveness. However, with careful planning and an eye on market trends, buying in bulk can lead to significant savings and quality control over your meals.

If feasible, buying a whole side of beef can be a surprisingly efficient option, offering both financial benefits and a satisfying stock of meat at home.

Factors Influencing Brisket Prices

Brisket pricing is influenced by various factors, including meat quality, purchase location, and market trends.

Higher-grade brisket with good marbling usually costs more, as do organic and grass-fed varieties. Wholesale clubs like Sam’s Club and Costco often offer brisket at lower prices due to bulk buying, making them good options for affordable purchases.

Supply and demand in the beef industry also impact brisket prices, with costs typically rising during BBQ season. The cut size and type, such as whole packer brisket, also affect the price, as does the preparation process.

Whether brisket is worth its price depends on personal preference.

For enthusiasts who relish tender, smoked meats, investing in quality brisket and learning cooking techniques can result in an exceptional meal. However, for those with varied meat preferences, waiting for sales or exploring other cuts might be more cost-effective. In the end, it’s about individual taste and the value placed on brisket’s unique flavor.

Picking Out Your Brisket

Choosing the right brisket involves several key decisions. For home-cooked family dinners, a flat cut, which is leaner and uniformly thick, is ideal. For larger outdoor gatherings, opt for a packer or whole brisket, which is bigger in size. When it comes to quantity, buy enough to suit your needs, considering the size of the gathering to ensure cost-effectiveness.

Quality-wise, look for brisket with consistent marbling, as it enhances flavor and texture. The brisket’s shape is also important; an evenly thick piece cooks more uniformly.

To save on costs, keep an eye out for sales and discounts. Warehouse stores like Costco often offer brisket at lower prices, especially when buying in bulk. Local butchers might have special deals or member discounts that can also help you save.

Let’s look at a few specifics!

Step 1: Choose Your Cut

Selecting the right brisket cut is crucial.

At your local butcher or supermarket, you’ll find two main types: the flat cut and the point cut. The flat cut is leaner, consistently thick, and perfect for uniform slices, making it ideal for sandwiches or plated dinners. It’s generally pricier due to its popularity. The point cut, or “deckle,” is fattier and imparts rich flavor, especially when cooked properly. It’s excellent for making burnt ends, a BBQ favorite.

Your choice depends on your cooking goals and preference for lean meat versus flavorful, fatty cuts.

Marbling, the thin fat threads in the meat, also plays a significant role in brisket’s juiciness and taste. It melts during cooking, enhancing the brisket’s richness. When shopping, consider the marbling and choose based on your taste for leanness or flavor.

Ask your butcher about marbling to ensure you get a piece that meets your culinary needs.

Step 2: Decide on Your Size

Selecting the right brisket size is crucial. For small family dinners, a brisket weighing 4-6 pounds is adequate. For larger gatherings, opt for bigger cuts, considering brisket shrinks by up to 40% during cooking.

Quality is also important, especially marbling, which ensures flavor and juiciness. Warehouse clubs like Costco and Sam’s Club are good for value and quality. Local butcher shops offer high-quality, locally sourced meats and might provide savings through sales or discounts.

Brisket prices fluctuate, so keep an eye on market trends. With the right strategies, brisket can be a cost-effective, delicious choice for any meal size.

Step 3: Go for Quality

Quality is crucial when shopping for brisket, even with cost considerations. High-grade cuts yield a more tender texture and richer flavor, essential for a satisfying meal. Opting for cheaper brisket might sacrifice these qualities.

Investing in better cuts from your local butcher enhances the end result, as butchers can guide you to the best options and offer cooking tips. When considering bulk purchases from warehouse clubs like Costco, prioritize quality. Check reviews and try smaller quantities first. Pay attention to marbling, as it significantly contributes to tenderness and flavor, especially in low-and-slow cooking.

Remember, the price of brisket often reflects its taste value. Despite various cost-saving strategies, don’t compromise on quality for the best culinary experience.

Step 4: Check for Marbling and Shape

Marbling and shape significantly impact brisket quality. Marbling, the fat within the meat, enhances juiciness and tenderness when cooked. However, too much fat can lead to wastage, while too little might result in dryness.

Shape matters for even cooking. Ideally, a brisket should have uniform thickness to avoid uneven cooking, with thinner ends possibly overcooking before thicker parts are done. A balanced, evenly shaped brisket ensures a better cooking outcome.

Local butchers can provide valuable advice on selecting cuts based on your intended cooking method, like smoking or barbecuing. Warehouse clubs like Costco and Sam’s Club are also good for economical bulk purchases.

Buying whole beef and freezing portions for later can be cost-effective in the long run. By focusing on marbling, shape, and size, you can balance quality and cost when buying brisket.

Not sure how to pick a good brisket?

Interestingly, this is the theme of a recent article I published. In it, I shared riveting info about brisket, such as what a good brisket looks like, which cut is the best, and whether Prime or Choice brisket is better.

Just click the link to read it on my site.

How much brisket per person should you serve?

A general rule of thumb is to plan to serve each person about ½ a pound of smoked brisket. 

For young people or small children, ¼ or ¾ per person may be ideal. But it’s okay to plan to serve ½ a pound per person.

You might be wondering if it’s a good thing to buy much raw brisket. Based on the potential loss, it’s better to buy a larger brisket, so that you’re sure you can accommodate everybody.

As you know, briskets require a long cooking time. So, it’s not something you can quickly whip up in case you need more. If you’ll prepare it yourself, it’s best to buy a pound of brisket per person because, as we learned earlier, you’ll lose about ½. So, plan to buy 1 pound of raw brisket per person.

Now, if you’ve ever wondered how to make steak tender, check out a recent article on my site.

In it, I shared what makes a good tenderizer, why your steak is tough and chewy, and whether cooking beef longer makes it tender, and I also offered 11 simple tips to make the meat tender.

Just click the link to read it on my site.

Cooking Brisket at Home

Cooking brisket at home is a rewarding experience for any meat lover. The key to a perfect brisket lies in slow and low cooking, which tenderizes the tough cut and enhances its flavor. Begin by selecting a well-marbled brisket for juiciness.

Rubbing the brisket with a mix of spices like salt, pepper, garlic powder, and paprika, and allowing it to marinate overnight, will enhance its taste.

For cooking, preheat your oven or smoker to 225°F. If using an oven, place the brisket fat-side up in a roasting pan, cover it with foil, and cook for about 1 hour per pound. In a smoker, maintain a consistent temperature, adding wood chips for smoke flavor, and cook for the same duration.

A crucial step is to monitor the internal temperature of the brisket, aiming for 190-200°F for optimal tenderness. Once done, let it rest for 30 minutes to an hour before slicing against the grain to serve.

Basting the brisket during cooking can keep it moist, and wrapping it in foil halfway through can prevent excessive drying. Cooking brisket at home requires patience but results in a flavorful, tender dish that’s ideal for gatherings or a special family meal.

Is Brisket Worth the Cost?

Yes, brisket is worth the cost for those who appreciate its unique qualities.

Brisket, known for its rich flavor and tender texture when cooked correctly, offers a distinct culinary experience. Its higher cost compared to other cuts of beef is due to its large size, the longer time it takes to raise the cattle, and the cooking process it requires.

The value of brisket lies in its versatility in various cooking methods, particularly slow-cooking techniques like smoking or braising, which bring out its depth of flavor. It’s a popular choice for barbecues and family gatherings, providing a substantial meal that serves many people.

For barbecue enthusiasts and meat lovers, the cost is justified by the end result – a flavorful, succulent dish that’s often the centerpiece of a meal. The satisfaction derived from successfully cooking a challenging cut like brisket also adds to its worth.

While the price may be higher than other meats, brisket’s unique taste and texture, coupled with the enjoyment it brings to culinary experiences, make it a worthwhile investment for those who prioritize quality and flavor in their meat choices.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the cost of brisket per pound varies significantly based on factors such as cut, quality, and regional pricing trends.

Generally, the price of brisket can range from as low as $3 per pound for a basic flat cut to upwards of $22 per pound for high-quality, Wagyu-style briskets. The choice between flat cut and point cut also plays a role in pricing, with point cuts often being slightly more expensive due to their higher fat content and richer flavor.

Geographical location and seasonality influence brisket prices too. In regions where barbecue is popular, brisket may be more competitively priced, especially during peak grilling seasons like summer and national holidays. Additionally, wholesale purchases from club stores like Costco or Sam’s Club can offer brisket at lower prices, though it typically requires buying in bulk.

For budget-conscious consumers, monitoring local sales and exploring local butchers or farmers’ markets can lead to finding brisket at more affordable rates. Upscale grocery stores or specialty meat shops tend to price brisket higher, reflecting the premium quality or specific breed of the cattle.

Ultimately, the price of brisket per pound is subject to a variety of influences, from the type of cut and quality to the location and season. While brisket can be a pricier meat option, its rich flavor and versatility in cooking make it a worthwhile purchase for many meat enthusiasts and barbecue aficionados.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can You Freeze a Brisket for Later?

Yes, you can freeze a brisket for later use.

Freezing brisket is an effective way to preserve its quality, extending its shelf life significantly. To properly freeze brisket, first ensure it’s cooled down if it has been cooked. For raw brisket, wrap it tightly in heavy-duty aluminum foil or plastic wrap, and then place it in a freezer bag to prevent freezer burn. Removing as much air as possible from the bag helps maintain its quality.

Frozen raw brisket can last for up to 12 months in the freezer without significant loss of flavor or texture.

Cooked brisket can also be frozen following the same wrapping method and will last for 2-3 months in the freezer. When you’re ready to use the frozen brisket, thaw it in the refrigerator for 24-48 hours before cooking or reheating. It’s important not to thaw brisket at room temperature, as this can lead to bacterial growth.

Freezing doesn’t significantly alter the taste or texture of brisket, making it a practical option for managing larger cuts or taking advantage of sales. This method is ideal for ensuring you always have brisket on hand for future meals.

Do you save money buying a pre-trimmed brisket?

The price differential between trimmed and untrimmed brisket is negligible. So, you’re not saving something substantial either way.

If you know how to trim brisket very well, you may want to do it yourself. Otherwise, you’ll probably be better off buying one that’s pre-trimmed. At least, you’ll save yourself time and won’t run the risk of trimming it too much.

Trimming brisket yourself can be tricky as there’s a need to find a sweet spot between leaving too much fat and eventually eating something a tad rubbery or cutting off too much fat and ending up with an overly dry brisket!

Is Wagyu brisket worth the extra cost? 

Yes, Wagyu brisket is worth the extra cost. It is highly marbled, which counteracts the drying of the meat while it’s being smoked. It’s also graded Prime by the USDA.

Wagyu is originally Japanese, so the grading system is a little bit different from what’s used by the USDA.

When it’s graded BMS 9, it’s a step higher than Prime, quality-wise.

It’s known for its intense flavor, fat, and tenderness. And it contains omega-3 fatty acids, which are good for the heart. The below depicts how Japanese Wagyu is classified.

• Japanese Black
• Japanese Brown
• Japanese Polled (not bred outside of Japan)
• Japanese Shorthorn (not bred outside of Japan)

Japanese Wagyu is not currently being imported. What we have were imported in the 80s and 90s. Only a few ranches breed 100 percent Japanese Wagyu. So, American Wagyu is a breed of the former American Angus or Hereford.

Snake River Farms offer the best quality Wagyu in the states.

They carefully manage their cattle in a manner that brings them pretty close in quality to their Japanese ancestors. They offer two grades of Wagyu: premium Gold Grade that has a BMS of 9+ and Black Grade.

Because Wagyu is highly marbled, you’ll need to trim it and also be patient when preparing it, as it will take a long time to render the fat down.

It’s believed to be the “secret weapon” of Myron Mixon, a 4-time World Barbecue Champion. Some seasoned smokers believe that Wagyu is the best brisket one can buy.

Ready to smoke a perfect brisket every time?

Check out this recent article on my other website that walks you through the brisket smoking process step-by-step. Just click that link to read it on my site.

Is Prime brisket worth the extra cost?

Yes, Prime brisket is worth the extra cost. It’s tender, flavorful, and juicier. It takes less time to prepare to boot. It’s ideal if you want great brisket.

As you know, Prime is the highest when we consider beef grades.

Beef is graded based on the degree of intramuscular fat and the age of the carcass when it was slaughtered. It’s no accident that Prime is number one on the list seeing as it’s produced from young, well-fed cattle.

It’s highly marbled, making it tender and flavorful. You can make good brisket with Choice, but if you want to take it up a notch, prime cuts are the way to go.

You’ve probably wondered how grocery stores keep meat fresh. 

You have, right? Find out in a recent article I published, where I shared how long grocery stores keep meat and how butchers keep meat fresh.

Just click the link to read it on my site.

How much is already smoked brisket per pound at restaurants?

You will find already smoked brisket per pound going for about $25 to $35 at a barbecue restaurant. 

But it can be higher in some barbecue joints! It turns out that the days when we saw brisket as one of the cheapest cuts of meat are probably over.

It’s very expensive! Yes, it is.

In a previous section, we’ve already explored why the price of raw briskets has soared in recent times. As you know, restaurants incur additional expenses to prepare smoked briskets. And they also have indirect overheads.

While seafood or pasta dishes take some minutes to prepare, smoked briskets take a lot of time. In some cases, they take over 10 hours to be ready! A lot goes into preparing smoked briskets.

Now, you can understand why it’s joined the rank of expensive meats.

In the past, the brisket wasn’t one of the beloved parts of a steer. It was often used for ground beef. Now, it’s enjoyed with a selection of savory side dishes.

Lots of people love steak. You’ve noticed the different grades of meat at the grocery store. But Prime beef can be pricey leading many to wonder is Prime steak worth it?

While USDA Prime does taste great, USDA Choice Grass-Fed steaks taste better. Despite minor differences between Certified Angus USDA Choice, regular USDA Choice, and USDA Prime, there was not a big enough difference to warrant the large price increase. So no, USDA Prime isn’t worth it.

But that doesn’t tell the whole story!

For the purposes of this article, I bought 4 steaks that are otherwise identical, but one was USDA Choice, one was USDA Prime, one was grass-fed USDA Choice, and one was USDA Choice Angus. I cooked them exactly the same for the same length of time and the same preparation (just salt and pepper).

So down below in our video taste test challenge, you’ll see how each tastes compared to the other!

The best grade of beef is Prime. Organic grass-fed beef is premium in terms of meat quality, taste, and health. Unfortunately, Prime beef is only available in small quantities to grocers due to its premium price and low demand.

So is it worth the price? What about Angus beef? Is Angus comparable to Prime beef?

Are you ready to know all you need to know about Prime steak and whether it’s worth the price?

Just keep reading!

Is Choice or Prime beef better?

Prime beef is better than Choice beef. The grading system determines the quality rating based on the amount of marbling in the muscle and the age of the beef. Marbling is basically fat, and a fattier cut of meat means more fat rendering (melting) out of the steak as it cooks. 

The United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) grades meat at the request of the meatpacker.

Traditionally a fattier cut of meat is richer and more flavorful. There are generally three USDA grades of beef that you would buy from the supermarket.

USDA Grading System

From highest to lowest, the grades of beef are:

• Prime
• Choice
• Select

USDA Prime

It is the most tender and flavorful cut of meat. It is also hard to find and usually reserved for high-end restaurants. You may be able to find it at the supermarket occasionally but at a premium price.

In short, the higher the ratio of marbling, and the younger the cow, the higher the grade.

The marbling determines the tenderness, juiciness, and flavor. Younger beef produces a finer texture, making it more tender.

USDA Choice

It has less marbling and is generally less tender. Less marbling also means less flavor and juice.

USDA Select is the lowest grade of steak you’ll find at the supermarket.

It is very lean and tougher than other cuts. USDA Cutter and Canner grades are meats that are typically found in convenience foods, like microwave burritos, pot pies, and other processed food products.

When shopping for steak, be sure to look for the USDA shield.

Many grocers will mark packages as “prime” or “choice,” but unless it has the USDA shield, it’s most likely a marketing ploy.

If you’re looking for the best steak, you may be surprised that size and fat content matter. To read about how to pick the best steak, read this recent article. There I also talk about which grocery store has the best steak.

Just click the link to read it on my site.

USDA Select

The USDA beef grade “Select” represents a category within the beef grading system that indicates a relatively lower level of marbling and tenderness compared to higher grades like “Choice” and “Prime.”

Beef labeled as “Select” typically comes from cattle with less intramuscular fat or marbling. This results in meat that is leaner and has fewer streaks of fat within the muscle tissue. As a consequence, “Select” beef tends to be less juicy and may be slightly less tender than higher-graded cuts.

While “Select” beef may not have the same level of marbling and tenderness as “Choice” or “Prime” cuts, it is still a suitable choice for various cooking methods. It can be flavorful when prepared with the right techniques, such as marinating or slow cooking, to enhance tenderness and taste.

pic.twitter.com/P2f0z7aiMs

— Middle Class Dad (@middleclassdad1) October 7, 2023

Is Angus better than Prime?

Not necessarily. Angus is a breed, not a grade. Angus, just like any other beef, can be terrible or excellent. It all depends on how the cow was grown, what the cow was fed, and whether it was given hormones or antibiotics.

Animals that are fed right and treated humanely are not just for marketing. They make for better tasting, healthier meat. As a bonus, you can feel good that the cow lived it’s best life before it ended up on your plate.

The American Angus Association and the Certified Angus Beef® brand are organizations that provide programs and services to “enhance the genetics of the Angus breed.”  Members pay dues to register their cattle and keep up-to-date on the Angus breed and the beef industry. (source)

They do not grade the beef as the USDA does.

The only requirement for meat to be labeled “Black Angus” is that the hide of the animal was at least 51% black. That’s it. It’s just the color of the hide. Not a better grade of beef. (source and source)

There are other requirements to be certified by USDA graders, but again, “Angus” is not a grade. “Angus” is a great marketing tool, but it doesn’t necessarily mean better beef.

But it’s worth noting that Angus beef ranchers can (and do) get USDA certified as the Angus steak I bought for the taste test was indeed USDA Choice.

While labels like “organic” can also be a marketing tool, when talking about beef, organically grown means that it is free from added hormones, antibiotics, and pesticides in its food. Organic and grass-fed cattle means that it hasn’t been fed any grain or soy.

So the best beef comes from cows that are raised organically and grass-fed.

But also bear in mind that organically-grown simply means that the food the cows eat isn’t treated with pesticides and that no artificial hormones or antibiotics are given to the cows.

Then grass-fed simply means the cow was fed grass rather than grains. And while organically-grown and grass-fed” are often lumped together, one doesn’t automatically mean the other.

After all, the steak I got for the taste test was grass-fed, but my local HEB did not have organically-grown ribeyes of any kind on the day I was there.

So with organically-grown, grass-fed, and organically-grown grass-fed, you can still have Select, Choice, or Prime grades. After all, those grades are basically for the marbling.

Some producers of grass-fed beef complain that grass-fed naturally makes the cows leaner, and thus not as marbled for the steaks. But we’ll let my taste buds decide down below in the taste test as to which is best.

Organic food is generally 10% to 20% more expensive than non-organic food.

That seems really high, but there is a good reason for that price difference. I explain the reasoning and the differences between organic and non-organic food in this recent article.

But I also tell you which foods actually tend to be less expensive when you buy them organically. And which of them are the most sprayed, and should always be bought organically.

Just click the link to read it on my site.

Prime Rib is second on the steak hierarchy only to Ribeye but its close. Look at this prefect slab of meat (I said what I said) pic.twitter.com/cAf564aDJ1

— Peter F (@Peterjf19) November 21, 2021

What percentage of steaks are Prime?

Approximately 2% of steaks will be USDA Prime. That’s due to the fact that only about five percent of all beef graded by the USDA qualifies for Prime distinction. Prime is often reserved for high-end restaurants and specialty grocers.

On the other hand, about 70% of all beef graded by the USDA gets the Choice distinction. (source)

This explains why Prime is so hard to come by in grocery stores. It also explains why Prime is so much more expensive. So if you don’t want to go out to a restaurant, where can you purchase Prime grade steak?

First, you should check your local meat market. You can also check online. Places like Snake River Farms and Kansas City Steaks sell Prime grade beef, but they can be even more expensive than eating out.

If you want to purchase your meat from the grocery store, check Costco or Whole Foods.

Remember, you should look for the USDA shield with the Prime label. Be on the lookout for grocery stores that just have the word “prime” in their labeling of meat. Without that shield, it’s not really Prime grade.

Our organic grass-fed beef is free from antibiotics, pesticides and hormones 🐄 #ingredientsmatter pic.twitter.com/IrcYuNQfxE

— Elevation Burger-KW (@ElevationKW) January 8, 2019

Is Costco Prime beef really Prime?

Yes. Costco is one of the few major chain stores that does carry a selection of USDA Prime beef. Unfortunately, they are not very transparent about where their meat comes from, and not everything they have labeled Prime is USDA Prime.

Costco does say that they are committed to “welfare, and proper handling, of all animals that are used in the production of products sold at Costco.” (source)

They also say that they feel like they have a moral and ethical obligation to the animals, but they don’t really go any further than that. Whole Foods Market, by comparison, has a very comprehensive animal welfare program they call their 5-Step Animal Welfare Rating system.

So, if you are looking for Prime grade meat that you can be certain is treated humanely, you may want to check out Whole Foods.

Whole Foods sells USDA Prime grade beef and they are committed to the humane treatment of all of the meat that is sold in their store.

Are you a chicken lover too?

I have a recent article that breaks down which grocery stores have the best quality chicken. It takes the mystery out of common terms like hormone-free and antibiotic-free.

Then, I even explain how some claims you see on chicken packages are just marketing gimmicks and are really meaningless.

Just click the link to read it on my site.

Wagyu Shaking Beef🔥
Flash-grill Smokey and Tender Wagyu Beef Cubes with Roasted Jasmine Rice Powder.#IRORI pic.twitter.com/xq5ggXqfkl

— IRORI (@IRORIsaudi) November 23, 2021

USDA Prime vs Wagyu beef; which is better?

Wagyu cattle have Japanese bloodlines and are raised in the US and other countries. Wagyu is extremely marbled. Even more than USDA Prime. It is also about twice the price of USDA Prime.

Japanese Wagyu is heavily regulated, and progeny testing is mandatory. This ensures people have only the highest quality meat.

Wagyu has a distinctive flavor and texture, but Japan stopped exporting Wagyu cattle in 1997.

Now, many American Wagyu is cross-bred with Angus to make them better adapted to the local climates and diseases. It also means that they are not as heavily regulated as Japanese Wagyu.

Even though American Wagyu does not have enforceable standards, the steaks are remarkable, with up to 30% fat. Wagyu fat melts at a lower temperature, resulting in a rich, buttery flavor. This makes it delicious and even better than Prime.

If you ever have the opportunity to eat Wagyu steak, you should absolutely do it.

What Do Top Chefs Think About USDA Prime Steaks?

Top chefs have a lot to say about USDA Prime steaks, and their opinions are highly regarded in the culinary world. Here’s what a few renowned chefs have to say, with their exact quotes:

Bobby Flay: “Spring for USDA Prime or Certified Black Angus steaks if you can. Choice-grade steak is a good, less-expensive alternative. Thin white streaks of fat throughout a steak, called marbling, keep the meat nice and juicy. Plus, the fat adds flavor.”

Matthew King, Executive Chef for Smith & Wollensky Steakhouse Chain: “The grade is a representation of marbling, but there’s a lot more that goes into how it tastes. Breed is important, and there’s a lot of Prime beef on the market now that is Holstein, dairy cattle, with much different taste, but still scoring Prime.”

Gordon Ramsay: “The quality of beef coming from the U.S. is astounding. We have some great heritage and rare breeds in the U.K., but even my London steak houses feature USDA prime beef. The beef itself is packed with unique flavor; it needs very little to shine on its own.”

These chefs unanimously emphasize the significance of USDA Prime steaks. Bobby Flay advises opting for them or Certified Black Angus if possible due to their superior quality. He highlights the importance of marbling, which not only keeps the meat juicy but also enhances flavor.

Matthew King adds depth to the discussion by noting that while marbling is crucial, breed also plays a significant role in taste. Even Prime beef can have different flavor profiles depending on the cattle’s breed.

Gordon Ramsay, known for his culinary expertise, praises the quality of U.S. beef, specifically USDA Prime. He underlines its unique flavor, indicating that it requires minimal seasoning to shine, making it a standout choice for steak aficionados.

How Much More Does Prime Beef Cost?

The cost of Prime beef is notably higher compared to lower-grade cuts due to its superior quality and desirable characteristics. Prime beef is renowned for its abundant marbling, which translates into enhanced tenderness and flavor. Here’s a breakdown of the price difference you can expect:

USDA Beef Grades: To understand the cost disparity, it’s essential to grasp the USDA beef grading system. Prime beef sits at the top, followed by Choice and Select grades. Prime steaks are marked by generous marbling, creating a tender, juicy, and flavorful eating experience.

Price Range: On average, Prime beef can cost about 50% to 100% more per pound compared to Choice-grade beef. This variance depends on factors like your location, the specific cut, and market fluctuations. For instance, a Prime ribeye steak might be significantly pricier than a Choice ribeye of the same weight.

Cut Matters: The type of cut also plays a role in pricing. High-demand cuts like ribeye, filet mignon, and New York strip tend to command a premium, regardless of the grade. As you move away from these prime cuts to less popular ones, the price gap between Prime and Choice may narrow.

Local Variations: Prices can vary regionally. In some areas, you might find Prime beef at a more reasonable cost, while in others, the premium might be steeper. Local factors like supply and demand, competition among retailers, and transportation costs all influence pricing.

Is It Worth It? The decision to splurge on Prime beef depends on your palate and preferences. If you prioritize an exceptionally tender, juicy, and flavorful steak, Prime is a worthy investment. On the other hand, if you’re more budget-conscious or plan to use marinades or sauces, Choice-grade beef can still provide a delightful dining experience.

Taste Test Results: Choice vs Prime vs Angus vs Grass-fed

For the taste test, I bought 4 boneless ribeye steaks of approximately the same weight, size, and thickness.

Specifically, they are each just under 1 lb and about an inch and a half thick.

One was USDA Choice beef, one was USDA Prime beef, one was certified Angus USDA Choice beef, and the other was grass-fed USDA Choice beef.

It’s also worth noting that the grass-fed and the Angus were also all-natural beef, meaning no artificial hormones or antibiotics.

Here’s a shot of each one and the price I paid for them:

USDA Prime – $17.27

USDA Choice – $9.45

Grass-fed USDA Choice – $16.32

Angus USDA Choice – $13.43

I cooked all of them for 4 1/2 minutes total, to an internal temp of about 145° for a nice medium.

For seasoning, I only added salt and pepper, grilling them on my Traeger Ironwood 650 grill at 400°, flipping once and rotating once on each side.

Here is a shot of the steaks resting after coming off the grill:

Then, I allowed each steak to rest off the grill for 5 minutes before cutting into it. I did not add steak sauce or anything that would cover the flavor of the meat or masque inferior flavor.

Final thoughts

In this article, we expanded on what it means to be a Prime steak.

We talked about the USDA grading process as well as where you can purchase Prime steak. Very few steaks are USDA Prime and they can be hard to come by at the grocery store. As a result, they are a bit pricier.

But in the end, we felt that USDA Choice Grass-Fed, which is a little cheaper than USDA Prime, was the tastier choice. Now, it’s up to you to decide!

When it comes to selecting the right cut of beef, it can be overwhelming trying to navigate the various options available. Two popular cuts that often cause confusion are chuck roast and chuck steak. So let’s explore the differences between chuck roast vs. chuck steak:

While they may sound similar, there are significant differences between the two that can affect the taste and texture of your dish.

Understanding the differences between these cuts of beef can help you make an informed decision and elevate your cooking game. In this article, we will explore the differences between chuck roast and chuck steak, their best uses, and cooking tips to help you create a delicious meal.

Key Takeaways:

• Chuck roast and chuck steak are cuts of beef that come from the shoulder area of the cow.
• Chuck roast is a tough cut of meat that benefits from long, slow cooking to become tender and flavorful.
• Chuck steak is a versatile beef cut that can be cooked using various methods, offering a rich and beefy flavor.
• When choosing between chuck roast and chuck steak, it’s important to consider your cooking method and personal preference.
• Consulting with a local butcher or reputable butcher shop can help you choose the right cut of meat for your needs.

Chuck roast is a popular choice for many slow-cooked dishes, thanks to its beefy flavor and tough nature. This cut of beef comes from the shoulder area of the cow and contains a good amount of connective tissue that requires longer cooking times to break down.

The best way to cook a chuck roast is to use slow cooking methods, such as in a slow cooker or a Dutch oven, with low heat to ensure that the connective tissue breaks down properly. This results in a tender and flavorful piece of meat that is perfect for a variety of dishes.

Boneless chuck roast is a popular choice for many dishes like beef stew and slow-cooked roasts with root vegetables. It is a versatile piece of meat that can handle long cooking times and is a popular choice for many popular dishes.

The cooking process for chuck roast can take a long time, but the end result is always worth it. Whether you are cooking a pot roast or pulled beef sandwiches, chuck roast is sure to deliver a satisfying and delicious meal.

Chuck Steak: A Versatile and Flavorful Beef Cut

Chuck steak is a popular beef cut that comes from the shoulder area of the cow. It is part of both the chuck and blade bone, which makes it a primal cut. Chuck steak is known for its rich flavor and can be an excellent choice for those who enjoy a beefy taste.

One of the most popular cuts of chuck steak is the flat iron steak, which is a smaller and more manageable cut compared to chuck roast. It is a better choice for those who prefer a more tender cut of meat.

When cooking chuck steak, it is essential to monitor the internal temperature using a meat thermometer. Overcooking can easily toughen the meat. Trimming excess fat from the steak can also enhance the taste and texture. Marinating chuck steak, especially with ingredients like red wine, can add depth to the flavor.

Chuck steak can be cooked using various methods, such as grilling, broiling, or braising. Grilling or broiling at high heat can create a delicious crust, while braising or marinating in a good marinade can add flavor and tenderness.

One of the best ways to enjoy chuck steak is by using it in recipes like steak fajitas, stir-fries, or even as a substitute for other beef cuts in recipes like beef stroganoff. Additionally, chuck steak can be cut into thinner slices to make denver steak, which is excellent for grilling or broiling.

Overall, chuck steak is a versatile and flavorful beef cut that can offer excellent results when cooked correctly. Its rich flavor and tender texture make it an excellent choice for those who enjoy the beefy taste of beef from the shoulder area of the cow.

Key Differences

When it comes to chuck roast and chuck steak, there are several key differences to consider. For starters, chuck roast is a tough cut of meat that requires longer cooking times to become tender. It also usually has an oblong shape and is a larger cut of meat than the chuck steak. Chuck steak, on the other hand, includes different cuts that are still from the shoulder area of the cow, but are usually smaller and more manageable. While still a tougher cut of meat, it is not as tough as the chuck roast and can be cooked using high heat methods like grilling or broiling. Overall, both cuts offer a rich and beefy flavor profile that is typical of tougher cuts of meat like the shoulder steak or tougher cuts of chuck meat.

To help remember the key differences between these cuts, remember that the chuck roast is generally a larger cut of meat with an oblong shape that requires longer cooking times. The chuck steak usually includes smaller cuts of meat that are not as tough as the chuck roast, allowing for different cooking methods like grilling or broiling. Both are still tough cuts of meat, but the chuck steak can be a better choice for those looking for a smaller cut or a more manageable cooking process.

Cooking Techniques and Tips

When it comes to cooking chuck roast and chuck steak, there are various techniques and tips one can employ to achieve tender and flavorful results. For chuck roast, it is best to use cooking techniques that involve longer cooking times and low temperatures, which will help break down the connective tissue and render a tender roast. A Dutch oven or slow cooker are excellent options for slow cooking, and adding root vegetables for the last hour of cooking can infuse the roast with extra flavor. For faster results, a pressure cooker can cut down on cooking times while still delivering excellent results.

When cooking chuck steak, high heat is often preferred to create a crusty exterior and a tender interior. Grilling and broiling at high heat are excellent options for cooking a delicious steak, and marinating the steak beforehand can help enhance the taste and tenderness. A good marinade can balance out the beefy flavor of the steak and add extra dimension to the flavor profile.

Other cooking methods for chuck steak include braising, stir-frying, and pan-searing. Depending on your preference, choosing the right cooking method can make all the difference in the final taste and texture of your dish.

Ultimately, experimenting with various cooking techniques and methods is key to discovering new ways to enjoy these cuts of beef. Whether you choose to use a Dutch oven, slow cooker, or grill, the right cooking technique can help bring out the best in chuck roast and chuck steak.

Best Uses and Recipes

Chuck roast and chuck steak are versatile beef cuts that can be used to create a wide range of delicious dishes. Here are some of the best uses and recipes for these cuts:

Chuck Roast

Chuck roast is an excellent choice for slow-cooked dishes that require rich, beefy flavor and a tender, juicy roast. Here are some of the best ways to use chuck roast:

• Pot Roast: A classic recipe that typically uses a boneless chuck roast. Slow-cook the roast with root vegetables, herbs, and broth for a satisfying meal.
• Beef Stew: Chuck roast can add depth to a hearty, savory beef stew. Add potatoes, carrots, and other vegetables for a complete one-pot meal.
• Roast Beef: Chuck roast is an affordable option for a juicy roast beef dinner. Slow-cook the roast to your desired temperature, and serve with your favorite sides.
• Slow Cooker Recipes: Chuck roast is a popular choice for slow cooker recipes due to its ability to become tender and flavorful over time. Try slow-cooker chili, pulled beef sandwiches, or shredded beef tacos.

Chuck steak is a versatile beef cut that can be used in many different recipes. Here are some of the best ways to use chuck steak:

• Steak Fajitas: Thinly sliced chuck steak can create delicious and flavorful steak fajitas. Sauté with onions and peppers, and serve with tortillas, salsa, and guacamole.
• Braised Beef: Chuck steak can add richness to a braised beef recipe. Simmer the steak in a savory sauce until it becomes tender and flavorful.
• Denver Steak: A thinner cut of chuck steak that is perfect for grilling or broiling. This steak is best served medium-rare, with a simple seasoning and a side of roasted vegetables.
• Beef Stroganoff: Use thinly sliced chuck steak in place of more expensive beef cuts in this classic pasta dish. It adds a rich, beefy flavor perfect for a hearty meal.

With these best uses and recipes, you’ll be able to make the most out of your chuck roast and chuck steak. Whether slow-cooked, braised, or grilled, these cuts of beef offer a rich and beefy flavor that is sure to satisfy your taste buds.

Choosing the Right Cut

Choosing the right cut of meat can be a daunting task, but fear not! Your local butcher shop or a reputable butcher can guide you through the different cuts available and recommend the best cut of meat based on your preferences and cooking method.

Butcher shops offer a wide variety of different cuts, each with their unique flavor and cooking method. Some cuts are best for grilling or broiling, while others are better suited for slow cooking or braising. Exploring the various cuts from different parts of the animal can introduce you to new flavors and textures, allowing you to expand your culinary repertoire.

Your local butcher can give you valuable advice on where each cut comes from, the specific characteristics of each cut, and the best cooking methods for that cut to achieve the desired result. They can also help you choose the right cut based on factors such as marbling, tenderness, and fat content.

So, next time you’re at the butcher shop, don’t be afraid to ask questions and seek advice. With their help, you can choose the right cut of meat and take your cooking to the next level.

Conclusion

In conclusion, understanding the main difference between chuck roast and chuck steak is crucial in making an informed decision when choosing the right cut of beef for your next meal. While chuck roast is a tough cut of meat that requires long, slow cooking to become a tender roast, chuck steak is a versatile cut that can be cooked using various methods, offering a rich and beefy flavor.

Both cuts offer a rich flavor profile typically associated with beef from the shoulder area of the cow, making them an excellent choice for those looking for a hearty and satisfying meal. Whether you prefer a tender roast or a well-seasoned steak, chuck roast and chuck steak have unique qualities that can enrich your cooking journey.

By experimenting with different cooking techniques and methods, you can create delicious, tender roasts or flavorful steak dishes. So next time you visit your local butcher shop, remember to ask for their recommendation and explore the various cuts available from different parts of the animal.

In the end, whether you prefer a tender roast or a well-seasoned steak, both chuck roast and chuck steak are an excellent choice for any occasion. So go ahead, make your informed decision, and enjoy the rich and beefy flavor of these tough cuts of meat.

FAQ

Q: What is the main difference between chuck roast and chuck steak?

A: The main difference lies in their intended use and cooking methods. Chuck roast is a tough cut of meat that benefits from long, slow cooking to become tender and flavorful. Chuck steak, on the other hand, is a versatile beef cut that can be cooked using various methods.

Q: How should I cook chuck roast?

A: Chuck roast is best cooked using slow cooking methods such as in a slow cooker or a Dutch oven. The long cooking time helps break down the connective tissue, resulting in a tender and flavorful roast.

Q: What are some popular dishes to make with chuck roast?

A: Chuck roast is often used in dishes like beef stew, pot roast, and slow-cooked roasts with root vegetables.

Q: How should I cook chuck steak?

A: Chuck steak can be cooked using various methods such as grilling, broiling, or braising. It is important to monitor the internal temperature using a meat thermometer and trim excess fat from the steak for best results.

Q: What are some popular dishes to make with chuck steak?

A: Chuck steak is often used in dishes like steak fajitas, stir-fries, and braised beef. The flat iron steak, which is part of the chuck steak, is a particularly popular choice for its tenderness and flavor.

Q: What is the key difference between chuck roast and chuck steak?

A: The main difference lies in their intended use and cooking methods. Chuck roast is a larger, oblong-shaped cut that benefits from long, slow cooking. Chuck steak is a smaller, more manageable cut that can be cooked using various methods.

Q: What are some recommended cooking techniques for chuck roast and chuck steak?

A: For chuck roast, it is best to use cooking techniques that involve longer cooking times and low temperatures, such as slow cookers, Dutch ovens, or braising. For chuck steak, grilling, broiling, or marinating in a good marinade can create delicious results.

Q: What are some best uses and recipes for chuck roast and chuck steak?

A: Chuck roast is ideal for dishes that require long, slow cooking, such as pot roast, beef stews, or pulled beef sandwiches. Chuck steak can be used in recipes like steak fajitas, stir-fries, or even as a substitute for other beef cuts in recipes like beef stroganoff.

Q: How can I choose the right cut between chuck roast and chuck steak?

A: It is recommended to consult your local butcher or visit a reputable butcher shop to understand the different cuts available and get recommendations based on your preferences and cooking method.

Q: What is the main takeaway from the differences between chuck roast and chuck steak?

A: The main difference lies in their toughness and cooking methods. Understanding these differences will help you make an informed decision and create delicious, tender roasts or flavorful steak dishes.

Meat departments often have dozens of choices, and typically put the oldest meat at the front. So what are the ways to tell if a steak is fresh in the grocery store?

To determine steak freshness in a grocery store, consider the following criteria: 

1. Observe a vibrant, cherry-red color (darker if vacuum-packed).
2. Feel for firmness upon touch.
3. Ensure the absence of off-odors.
4. Check the packaging for minimal liquid and no punctures.
5. Confirm the use-by date is within the consumption period.

In this blog post, we’ll provide you with the knowledge and tools to select the freshest, tastiest steaks for your next culinary adventure.

Short Summary

• Bright red hues indicate fresh steak, while brown and grey tones should be approached with caution.
• Firmness of a steak can determine its freshness. It should bounce back when pressed.
• Proper packaging, expiration dates and smell are all indicators of the quality of a steak.

How Steak Color Can Determine Freshness

A steak’s color can be a telling indicator of its freshness. In fact, it’s the best way to tell. Bright red hues signify a fresh, ready-to-cook steak, while a brown steak or gray tones suggest that caution should be exercised.

It’s important to note that while color can be a helpful guide, it’s essential to consider other factors as well to ensure you’re choosing the best steak for your meal.

Bright Red Hues: Fresh and Ready to Cook

Fresh red meat, like steaks, typically exhibit a vivid red hue, signaling that they are suitable for cooking. This bright red color is a sure sign of freshness, so when shopping for steaks, keep an eye out for this vibrant hue to ensure you’re buying a quality cut of meat.

It’s important to remember that the color of the steak is not the only indicator of freshness.

Brown or Gray Tones: Proceed with Caution

Steaks with brown or gray tones may not necessarily be spoiled, but it’s wise to proceed with caution before consuming them. Factors such as the animal’s age, muscle usage, and diet can affect the color of raw steak, leading to these less appealing hues.

Too much lactic acid can also cause meat to turn brown.

Lactic acid in beef though has nothing to do with freshness since that can’t increase after slaughter.

If you encounter gray or brown meat, it’s crucial to check for other signs of spoilage, such as odor, texture, and packaging, before deciding whether it’s safe to eat. While color alone may not definitively indicate spoilage, it’s always better to err on the side of caution to minimize the risk of food poisoning.

Are Dry-Aged Steaks Darker in Color Than Non-Aged Meat?

Dry-aged steak does exhibit a darker hue compared to its non-aged counterparts.

Here’s why: as beef ages, moisture evaporates and the meat naturally oxidizes, leading to a richer, almost mahogany appearance. This isn’t a sign of spoilage; it’s a mark of a meticulous aging process, which concentrates flavors and tenderizes the meat.

The exterior might even form a hard crust, which butchers trim off before selling.

Inside that crust, the steak’s color, texture, and flavor have transformed. The dry-aging process, often lasting anywhere from 21 to 120 days, allows enzymes to break down tough muscle fibers and amplifies the beefy flavor. So, when you spot a darker steak at the butcher’s, it could well be a sign of that deep, nuanced taste dry-aged fans rave about.

Remember, it’s not just about color; it’s about the rich, intensified flavor that many steak aficionados swear by.

How Steak Firmness Can Determine Freshness

Another key factor in determining steak freshness is its firmness.

Fresh steak should bounce back when pressed gently, while a spoiled steak may remain indented. By evaluating the firmness of a steak, you can better ensure that you’re selecting a fresh, delicious cut of meat for your meal.

Fresh Steak: Bounces Back

When shopping for steak, gently press the meat with your finger. Fresh steak should be resilient and bounce back, indicating that it’s ready for cooking. This simple test can help you avoid selecting a spoiled steak and ensure that you’re purchasing a quality cut of meat for your meal.

Spoiled Steak: Remains Indented

In contrast, spoiled steak may remain indented after being pressed, suggesting that it’s no longer fresh and may not be safe to eat. If you find a steak that remains indented after pressing, it’s best to avoid it and look for a firmer, fresher option to ensure a delicious and safe dining experience.

When selecting a cooked steak, it’s important to look for one that is firm and resilient.

How Steak Moisture Can Determine Freshness

Moisture levels in steak can also help you determine its freshness. Fresh steak should be lightly moist, while spoiled steak may be excessively wet or slimy. By paying attention to the moisture levels in your steak, you can better assess its quality and avoid disappointment at the dinner table.

Fresh Steak: Lightly Moist

When examining steak for freshness, look for a moderate moisture level.

Fresh steak should be neither excessively dry nor overly moist, indicating that it’s in prime condition for cooking. The texture of fresh steak should also be firm and slightly resilient, without any slime or tackiness. While dry aged steak is known for its unique flavor and tenderness, it’s important to ensure the freshness of any steak before cooking.

When handling steak, it’s important to be gentle. Avoid squeezing or pressing the steak too hard.

Spoiled Steak: Excessively Wet or Slimy

If you notice that the surface of the steak is excessively wet or has a slimy film on the surface of the meat, this is one of the tell-tale signs of harmful bacteria growth and spoilage, similar to rotten meat. The slimy or sticky texture of the meat indicates that it’s no longer fresh and may not be safe to eat bad steak.

So it’s a good idea to avoid purchasing the slimy steak and instead look for a cut with a more appropriate moisture level. By being vigilant about moisture levels and texture, you can ensure that you’re choosing a fresh, delicious steak for your meal.

If you have already bought it, it’s best to toss it in the trash.

How Steak Smell Can Determine Freshness

The smell of a steak is another valuable indicator of its freshness.

A fresh steak should have a mild, metallic scent, while a spoiled steak may have a bad smell that smells sour or has an ammonia-like odor. By using your sense of smell, you can further ensure that you’re selecting the freshest possible cut of meat for your meal.

Fresh Steak: Mild and Metallic Scent

Fresh steak typically has a faint, metallic scent, which is normal for raw meat. This mild aroma is a good sign of freshness and can help you feel confident in your steak selection.

When shopping for steak, it’s important to look for cuts that are bright red in color.

Spoiled Steak: Sour or Ammonia-Like Odor

On the other hand, spoiled steak may emit a sour or ammonia-like odor, suggesting that it’s no longer fresh and may not be safe to eat. This strong, unpleasant smell is a telltale sign of bacterial growth and spoilage, so it’s best to avoid steaks with this odor to prevent potential foodborne illnesses. In this case, one could say that steak is bad for consumption.

Remember, your sense of smell is an invaluable tool when it comes to selecting the freshest steak. By paying close attention to the aroma of your prospective steak, you can make informed decisions and enjoy a delicious, satisfying meal.

Steak Packaging and Expiration Dates: Know What to Look For

Proper packaging and understanding expiration dates can be crucial in ensuring that you’re purchasing fresh steak. By knowing what to look for on your package of meat, you can make confident choices and enjoy a quality dining experience.

When shopping for steak, look for packages that are sealed tightly and have no signs of damage.

Proper Packaging: Vacuum-Sealed or Tightly Wrapped

When selecting steak, look for vacuum-sealed or tightly wrapped packaging to ensure freshness.

Vacuum-sealed packaging helps maintain freshness by removing air and preventing freezer burn, while tightly wrapped packaging, such as plastic wrap or butcher paper, can also keep the steak fresh by reducing exposure to air and minimizing moisture loss. Additionally, choosing a frozen steak can be a great option for long-term storage without compromising quality.

By choosing steaks with proper packaging, you can feel confident in the freshness and quality of your raw beef, ensuring a delicious and enjoyable meal with fresh meat.

Expiration Dates: Sell-By vs. Use-By

It’s essential to understand the difference between sell-by and use-by dates when purchasing steak. The sell-by date is the last day the store should sell the steak, while the use-by date is the last day the steak should be cooked or frozen. By being aware of these dates, you can avoid potential spoilage and ensure a fresh, delicious cut of meat.

Remember to always consume or freeze your steak before its use-by date to avoid potential foodborne illness. By paying close attention to expiration dates and packaging, you can make informed decisions and enjoy a quality dining experience.

Summary

In conclusion, understanding the signs of freshness in steak, such as color, firmness, moisture, odor, and packaging, can help you make informed choices and ensure a delicious, enjoyable meal.

Grocery store meat is generally very high quality and has been held to the high standards set by the United States Department of Agriculture, and has also been inspected.

By following the guidelines outlined in this blog post, you can confidently select the freshest steaks and avoid potential health risks. So go ahead, put your newfound knowledge into practice, and enjoy the taste of a perfectly cooked, fresh steak.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can you tell if a steak is fresh?

To tell if a steak is fresh, check the texture – it should not be slimy. Smell the beef – it should not have an ammonia or sulfur smell. Feel the beef – it should not be tacky to the touch.

Finally, look for any discoloration or signs of its expiration date passing.

How can I tell if a steak is fresh by its color?

A fresh steak should have bright red hues; brown or gray tones may indicate spoilage, so inspect the steak carefully.

What is the difference between sell-by and use-by dates?

The sell-by date indicates when the store should stop selling the item, while the use-by date is the last day the item should be consumed.

---

Crowd Cow in a vacuum sealed bags by sousvideguy is licensed under CC2.0

Navigating the meat department at the grocery store can be a confusing experience with labels displaying terms such as select, choice, and prime. It’s easy to feel overwhelmed, uncertain of which one promises the juiciest, most flavorful steak. So let’s talk about demystifying and understanding steak grading.

Steak grading, assigned by the USDA, categorizes beef based on tenderness, juiciness, and flavor. The main grades are Prime, indicating high quality with abundant marbling; Choice, offering less marbling but good flavor; and Select, leaner cuts with modest tenderness.

Grading systems provide valuable information about the quality, tenderness, and flavor of the meat, empowering you to make informed decisions and elevate your dining experiences, whether at home or in restaurants. Ready to become a steak connoisseur?

Let’s dive into the world of steak grading!

Short Summary

• Understand the USDA and international beef grading systems to find quality cuts.
• Marbling, genetics, diet & exercise affect intramuscular fat distribution for flavor & texture outcomes.
• Yield grade informs consumer choices while source, aging process & cooking techniques influence steak quality.

USDA Beef Grading System

The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) beef grading system classifies beef into eight categories based on marbling and cattle maturity. (source)

With beef grades explained you can understand that the top three USDA beef grades available to consumers are Prime, Choice, and Select. These beef quality grades help you understand the tenderness, juiciness, and flavor you can expect from your steak, ultimately guiding your choices as you navigate the world of beef.

Understanding the USDA beef grading system can help you make informed decisions when selecting beef. Knowing the facts is important.

USDA Prime Beef

USDA Prime grade beef represents the pinnacle of quality, renowned for its abundant marbling, tenderness, and flavor.

Sourced from young, well-fed cattle, Prime beef features 8-13% fat content, making it an excellent choice for grilling and high-end dining experiences. You’ll often find prime-grade beef in upscale dining establishments like high-end restaurants, steakhouses, and hotels due to its exceptional taste and texture.

USDA Prime steak and roasts are best suited for dry-heat cooking methods, such as broiling, roasting, or grilling, enhancing their tenderness and juiciness.

USDA Choice Beef

Choice beef is a high-quality option with slightly less marbling than Prime, yet maintaining excellent tenderness, juiciness, and flavor. Choice beef is more commonly found in casual dining restaurants and grocery stores, making it accessible for everyday enjoyment.

The loin and rib cuts of Choice grade beef are particularly tender, juicy, and flavorful, making them perfect for dry-heat cooking methods like grilling, pan-frying, or broiling.

USDA Select Beef

USDA Select beef is a leaner cut compared to Choice beef, with less marbling.

This results in decreased levels of tenderness, juiciness, and flavor. Although not as tender as its higher-grade counterparts, Select beef is a more affordable option that can still yield satisfactory results when cooked with care.

To optimize its taste and texture, Select grade beef benefits from smoking, braising, or stewing techniques to reintroduce moisture into the meat.

While technically not the lowest grade beef (cuts not even able to be graded select may end up in pet food), USDA Select is likely the lowest grade you’ll see on your grocer’s shelves.

Japanese & Australian Beef Grading System

Beyond the USDA grading system, other countries have their own distinct methods of evaluating beef quality.

The Japanese and Australian grading systems focus on marbling, meat color, and texture, with Japan’s A5 grade and Australia’s 5-star MSA (Meat Standards Australia) grade representing the highest quality beef. These international systems offer alternative ways to assess and appreciate the nuances of beef quality, further broadening your culinary horizons.

In Japan, the A5 grade is famed for its unparalleled flavor and tenderness, making it highly sought after by discerning diners. Kobe beef, a type of Wagyu beef originating from the Tajima strain of cattle in Japan’s Hyogo Prefecture, is a prime example of the exceptional quality achievable through Japan’s grading system.

Meanwhile, Australia’s MSA system evaluates beef based on marbling, tenderness, and flavor, with the 5-star MSA grade representing the pinnacle of quality. Understanding these international grading systems can help you explore the diverse world of steak and make even more informed choices when selecting the perfect cut.

The Science Behind Marbling on Beef

Marbling, or intramuscular fat distribution, plays a significant role in beef grading, affecting tenderness, juiciness, and flavor. Those white flecks of fat within the meat contribute to its rich taste and mouthwatering tenderness. To ensure the highest quality, it’s essential to measure meat characteristics, such as marbling and intramuscular fat distribution.

But what causes marbling, and how does it vary between different cuts of beef?

Intramuscular Fat Distribution

Intramuscular fat distribution refers to the pattern and location of fat within the muscle tissue. The amount of intramuscular fat can vary due to factors such as genetics, diet, and exercise. Higher marbling levels, resulting from a favorable combination of these factors, lead to higher beef grades and a more satisfying dining experience.

Factors Affecting Marbling

Several factors influence marbling in the meat, including genetic factors like cattle breed and sexual characteristics, nutritional factors such as the cattle’s diet, and management factors like raising and feeding techniques.

Different cuts of meat may also naturally accumulate varying levels of marbling, further contributing to the diversity of flavors and textures found in different steak cuts.

By understanding the factors that affect marbling, you can better appreciate the nuances of beef quality and make more informed choices when selecting a steak.

Beef Yield Grade and Usable Lean Meat

Beef yield grade is an indicator of the amount of usable lean meat on a carcass.

While not as well-known as quality grades like Prime, Choice, and Select, yield grade plays an important role in informing consumer choices and pricing. Understanding yield grade can help you make more informed decisions about the quality and value of the beef you purchase.

Yield grade is determined by a trained grader who evaluates the amount of fat and lean meat, ensuring a quality grade assessment. Butchers at butcher shops are more likely to be fully trained in this area than an ordinary grocery store employee.

Calculating Yield Grade

Yield grade is determined by an equation that considers factors like external fat thickness, ribeye area, and the respective percentages of kidney, heart, and pelvic fat. The resulting whole number grade, with any fractional or decimal component discarded, provides an estimate of the amount of boneless, trimmed beef cuts that can be obtained from a single carcass for wholesale marketing.

Yield grade is an important factor in determining the value of a carcass, as it is an important factor in determining the value of the carcass.

Impact on Consumer Choices

Although yield grade is not a major factor in consumer choices, it can still provide useful information about the amount of carcass that can be sold as wholesale or retail cuts. By considering yield grade alongside quality grades like Prime, Choice, and Select, you can make more informed decisions about the beef you purchase. This ensures that you get the best value for your money and the best taste for your palate.

Beyond Grading: Other Factors Influencing Steak Quality

While grading systems provide valuable insights into beef quality, other factors also play a crucial role in determining the taste and texture of your steak. The source and diet of cattle, the aging process, and cooking techniques can all influence the quality of your dining experience, ultimately shaping the perfect steak.

Grading systems are just one piece of the puzzle. To truly enjoy the best steak possible, it’s essential to consider higher grades of meat quality.

Source and Diet of Cattle

The source and diet of cattle are integral in determining steak quality. Cattle raised on grass-fed diets tend to yield steaks with more flavor and improved texture compared to those that are grain-fed. The genetic capability of cattle to grow and effectively convert feed into weight gain also plays an important role in the quality of the meat.

Understanding the origins and dietary habits of the cattle used to produce your steak can help you make more informed choices and appreciate the nuances of beef quality.

Aging Process

The aging process, either dry or wet aging, can enhance the tenderness and flavor of beef, adding to its overall quality. Dry aging involves storing beef in a temperature and humidity-controlled environment for a certain period of time, allowing the beef to lose moisture and develop a more concentrated flavor.

Wet aging, on the other hand, involves allowing the beef to age in a vacuum-sealed bag, retaining its moisture and resulting in a more tender steak. By understanding the impact of the aging process on beef quality, you can enhance your dining experience and appreciate the subtle differences between various cuts of steak.

Cooking Techniques

Proper cooking techniques, such as grilling, pan-searing, or slow cooking, can significantly impact the taste and texture of beef, regardless of its grade. Grilling and pan-searing are excellent methods for enhancing the flavor of steaks like ribeye and sirloin, while slow cooking can bring out the tenderness in cuts like tenderloin/filet mignon.

By mastering the art of cooking techniques, you can elevate the taste and texture of your steak, ensuring a satisfying and memorable dining experience.

Popular Steak Cuts and Their Grading Characteristics

Each popular steak cut, such as ribeye, sirloin, tenderloin/filet mignon, and T-bone, boasts unique grading characteristics based on their marbling, tenderness, and flavor. By understanding the differences between these cuts and their grading characteristics, you can select the perfect cut for your taste preferences and dining occasion.

Grading characteristics vary from cut to cut. Ribeye steaks are known for their marbling.

Ribeye

Ribeye steaks are known for their rich flavor and tenderness due to their high marbling levels, making them a popular choice for grilling and pan-searing. The high-fat content in ribeye steaks contributes to their succulent, beefy flavor and mouthwatering tenderness, ensuring a satisfying and indulgent dining experience.

Sirloin

Sirloin steaks offer a balance of tenderness and flavor, suitable for various cooking methods and often found in casual dining establishments. With a solid blend of taste and texture, sirloin steaks provide a versatile and enjoyable option for steak lovers.

They are a great choice for those looking for a steak that is both flavorful and tender. S.

Tenderloin/Filet Mignon

Tenderloin/filet mignon is the most tender part of the cow, with a mild flavor and lower marbling levels, making it a luxurious and lean option. Ideal for special occasions and fine dining experiences, tenderloin/filet mignon steaks exude elegance and sophistication.

New York Strip

The New York strip steak is a renowned cut that originates from the cow’s short loin, located behind the ribcage.

This location means it doesn’t do as much work as other muscles, resulting in a particularly tender piece of meat. What sets it apart is its characteristic fine marbling — thin streaks of fat interspersed within the meat. This marbling ensures every bite is juicy, flavorful, and melt-in-your-mouth tender.

While it shares the stage with other popular cuts like the ribeye, the New York strip is often favored for its leaner profile. However, despite having less fat overall, it still packs a robust, beefy flavor that has won the hearts of steak lovers worldwide. When perfectly cooked, its rich taste and slightly chewy texture offer a unique dining experience, making it a staple in steakhouses and kitchens alike.

Whether grilled, broiled, or pan-seared, this steak is a delightful treat for the palate.

T-Bone Steak

The T-bone steak is a cut that’s like getting two steaks in one, and it hails from the front section of the short loin on the cow.

The standout feature of this steak is the T-shaped bone that divides two different meat textures: on one side, you’ve got the tenderloin (which is super soft and delicate), and on the other, the strip loin (meaty and flavorful).

It’s like the best of both worlds on a single plate. This unique combination allows steak enthusiasts to enjoy varying textures and flavors in one bite. Unlike singular cuts like the ribeye or sirloin, the T-bone offers a more diverse taste experience.

When cooked just right, it’s a juicy, flavorful masterpiece. Its bone not only gives the steak its iconic appearance but also adds depth to its taste, making the T-bone a favorite choice for many looking for a comprehensive steak experience.

Summary

In the world of steak, knowledge is power.

By understanding the various grading systems, such as the USDA, Japanese, and Australian grading systems, and the factors that influence beef quality, you can make more informed decisions when selecting and cooking your steak. From the rich, tender ribeye to the luxurious, lean tenderloin/filet mignon, there’s a perfect steak cut and grade to suit every palate and occasion.

Embrace your inner steak connoisseur and use your newfound understanding of steak grading to elevate your dining experiences. Whether you’re grilling at home or indulging in a high-end restaurant, knowing the nuances of beef quality will help you savor each bite and appreciate the art of steak.

Frequently Asked Questions

What grade of steak is the best?

USDA. Prime is the highest grade of steak available, boasting a rich, beefy flavor, abundant marbling, and superior tenderness. It’s the most expensive grade but offers the best quality experience.

What are the grades of steaks?

The eight beef quality grades, based on the degree of marbling and maturity, are Prime, Choice, Select, Standard, Commercial, Cutter & Canner.

What is the difference between Grade AAA and AA beef?

Grade AAA beef has more marbling, making it more flavorful and juicy, resulting in a premium often being paid for the higher grade cuts.

Compared to Grade AAA, Grade AA beef has slightly less marbling.

What is the highest grade of beef in the Japanese grading system?

The highest grade of beef in the Japanese grading system is A5, offering unbeatable quality and flavor.

What factors affect the marbling in beef?

Marbling in beef is affected by genetics, nutrition, and cattle management practices.

Looking for the best steaks (and ground beef, chicken, or pork) and unhappy with what your local store has?

Now thanks to FarmFoodsMarket, you can get 100% grass-fed steaks delivered right to your door.

Once you try it, you’ll be astounded at how much better the quality is! Imagine the taste of that grass-fed ribeye fresh off your grill!

Enjoy 10% off your first order with code WELCOME on FarmFoodsMarket.com!

No doubt you’ve seen FarmFoodsMarket raved about by Forbes and The Washington Post. Now it’s your turn!

Just chose the steak that’s right for you or their value pack combination boxes; beef, chicken, or the best of both. Flash-frozen and vacuum-sealed means it will be farm fresh whenever you’re ready!

With every purchase, you support building a better food system for the animals, the planet, and us. Humanly raised and processed.

CLICK HERE to see all their amazing offerings on their website.

---

USDA Choice Beef by Steve Snodgrass is licensed under CC2.0

The debate between conventional and organic foods has always been a hot topic in culinary circles. For meat lovers, the discussion often centers around the flavor profile of steak. So let’s answer the question of organic vs. conventional steak: Which tastes better?

Organic steaks have a richer, more natural flavor due to their diet and rearing practices. Conventional steaks might be more consistent in taste due to standardized farming methods.

Ultimately, flavor preference varies individually.

In this article, we’ll provide a comprehensive comparison of these two types of steaks, enabling you to make an informed and delicious decision: organic vs conventional steak, which tastes better?

Short Summary

• Organic grass-fed beef offers a unique flavor profile, is leaner and chewier in texture, and has lower calorie content with higher levels of omega-3 fatty acids & conjugated linoleic acid (CLA).
• Conventional grain-fed beef has a sweeter & juicer taste but may have fewer health benefits. It is more tender in texture with higher fat content.
• When selecting a steak, consider personal preferences as well as potential health impacts and environmental sustainability to make an informed choice that best suits your values.

Organic vs Conventional Steak: Understanding the Differences

Organic and conventional steaks vary in several significant ways, including cow diet, living conditions, and production methods.

Organic grass-fed beef is sourced from cows that have grazed on pasture and foraged for their own fresh food, resulting in fewer chemical inputs and a more natural diet. On the other hand, conventional grain-fed beef typically comes from cows raised in feedlots and fed a high-grain diet, often including corn by-products and other grain feeds.

These differences in diet and living conditions have a direct impact on the nutritional content and flavor of beef.

Knowing the benefits of consuming beef from grass-fed cattle and/or beef from organic farming is essential due to the daily exposure our bodies have to agrochemicals such as Glyphosate. As a result, it is crucial to be aware of the toxicity of conventionally grown crops and livestock, which can be detrimental to human health.

Cow Diet and Nutrition

The dietary habits of cows have a direct effect on the nutritional content and flavor of beef, with grass-fed cows having a more natural diet compared to grain-fed cows.

Grass-fed cows are allowed to graze and forage for their own fresh food on pasture, which is more in line with their natural environment. This results in a more flavorful and nutritious beef, as the nutrients present in the cow’s diet are reflected in the meat.

On the other hand, grain-fed cows are often raised in feedlots and fed a high-grain diet, including corn by-products and other fed grain feeds.

This diet can lead to a sweeter, juicier taste in the beef due to the higher fat content from more marbling. However, this also means that grain-fed beef may contain a higher amount of saturated fat and fewer essential nutrients, such as omega-3 fatty acids, compared to grass-fed beef.

For those who prefer the taste and don’t mind the trade-off in nutrients, they might choose to eat grain-fed beef.

Cattle Living Conditions

Cattle living conditions can greatly influence the quality of the meat, with organic grass-fed cows usually having better living conditions than conventional grain-fed cows.

Organic grass-fed cows are typically reared on pasture and not administered antibiotics or hormones, leading to healthier animals with higher levels of omega-3 fatty acids and conjugated linoleic acid (CLA). In contrast, cows in the grain fed beef industry are often raised in more confined environments, which can impact the nutritional profile of the meat.

In contrast, conventional grain-fed cows are commonly raised in feedlots and given antibiotics and hormones. These living conditions can result in a less healthy animal with lower levels of essential nutrients and higher levels of saturated fat. Additionally, conventional beef production generates more greenhouse gas emissions compared to organic grass-fed beef production.

Beef Production Methods

The production methods for organic and conventional steaks differ in terms of chemical inputs, GMOs, and hormones used. Organic beef production does not make use of GMOs, antibiotics, or hormones, ensuring a more natural and safer product for consumers.

This is particularly important given the presence of cancer-causing herbicides like Glyphosate in conventionally grown crops and livestock.

On the other hand, conventional grain-fed beef production relies on chemical inputs and the use of antibiotics and growth hormones. These practices can lead to an increased risk of exposure to harmful chemicals and a less healthful product overall. As a result, organic grass-fed beef offers a safer and more nutritious alternative for consumers.

Flavor Profiles: Organic Grass-Fed vs Conventional Grain-Fed Beef

The distinct flavor profiles of organic grass-fed and conventional grain-fed beef can greatly influence personal preferences. Organic grass-fed beef is known for its more natural, game-like flavor due to the cow’s diet, while conventional grain-fed beef offers a sweeter, juicier taste as a result of the high-grain diet and marbling.

Ultimately, the choice between these two flavor profiles will come down to individual taste preferences of steak eaters.

Organic Grass-Fed Beef Taste

The taste of organic grass-fed beef is distinct due to the nutrients present in its fat, and some people even notice that grass-fed beef smells different.

The cow’s diet, which consists mainly of grass, imparts a more natural, game-like flavor to the meat. This unique taste can be attributed to the higher concentrations of beta-carotene naturally present in the grass, which gives the fat in grass-fed beef a rich yellow shade.

For those who appreciate a more natural and earthy flavor, organic grass-fed beef provides a palate-pleasing option.

The unique taste profile of grass-fed beef can be further enhanced by proper cooking techniques, such as searing at high heat to develop a flavorful crust while maintaining a tender, juicy interior. Enjoying a grass-fed burger is a great way to experience these flavors.

Conventional Grain-Fed Beef Taste

Conventional grain-fed beef, on the other hand, is characterized by a sweeter, juicier taste due to the cow’s high-grain diet. The higher marbling and fat content in grain-fed beef contributes to its tender texture and rich flavor. For some, this sweeter and juicier taste may be more appealing than the natural, game-like flavor of grass-fed beef.

However, it is important to note that the sweeter flavor of grain-fed beef comes at the cost of higher fat content and potentially fewer health benefits compared to the health benefits of grass-fed beef. Thus, when choosing between grass-fed and grain-fed beef, it’s essential to weigh taste preferences against potential health concerns.

Texture and Tenderness: Comparing Organic and Conventional Steaks

Beyond taste, the texture and tenderness of organic grass-fed and conventional grain-fed steaks also differ. Grass-fed beef is typically chewier due to its leaner composition, while grain-fed beef boasts a more tender texture thanks to its higher marbling and fat content.

This contrast in texture and tenderness can influence personal preferences and the overall enjoyment of the steak.

Organic Grass-Fed Beef Texture

The leaner and chewier texture of beef from organic producers is a result of its lower marbling and fat content. This leaner composition can be attributed to the cow’s more natural diet of grass, which provides essential nutrients and beta-carotene without the added fat found in a grain-based diet.

For those who prefer a chewier texture in their steak, organic grass-fed beef is an excellent choice. The unique texture of grass-fed beef can be further accentuated by proper cooking techniques, such as cooking to medium rare to maintain tenderness while still delivering that satisfying chew.

Conventional Grain-Fed Beef Texture

In contrast, conventional grain-fed beef is known for its more tender texture due to its higher marbling and fat content. The cow’s high-grain diet contributes to this increased marbling, providing a rich and satisfying mouthfeel that many steak lovers enjoy.

For those who prefer a more tender texture in their steak, conventional grain-fed beef is an appealing option. However, it’s essential to consider the trade-offs, as the more tender texture comes with higher fat content and potentially fewer health benefits compared to grass-fed beef.

What’s the Healthier Option: Organic or Conventional Steak?

When comparing the health benefits of organic grass-fed and conventional grain-fed steaks, organic grass-fed beef emerges as the healthier option due to its fewer calories, higher levels of omega-3 fatty acids, and more conjugated linoleic acid (CLA).

While conventional grain-fed beef offers a sweeter, juicier taste, it comes at the cost of a higher calorie content and potentially fewer health benefits. In this context, choosing a grass fed steak can be a more nutritious choice.

Organic grass-fed beef is a healthier option due to its lower calorie content and higher calorie content.

Omega-3 Fatty Acids

Organic grass-fed beef is a richer source of omega-3 fatty acids compared to conventional grain-fed beef. Essential fatty acids have been linked to improved cardiovascular health, making grass-fed beef a heart-healthy choice.

The cow’s diet plays a significant role in the higher omega-3 fatty acid content in grass-fed beef. As cows eat grass and graze on pasture, they consume grass and other forage that naturally contain higher concentrations of these essential nutrients.

Conjugated Linoleic Acid (CLA)

Grass-fed beef is considered a healthier option when compared to commercially raised meats, and eating grass-fed beef can provide numerous benefits. Grass-fed meat, like grass fed beef, is also a rich source of conjugated linoleic acid (CLA).

CLA has demonstrated immunomodulatory qualities. This can assist in safeguarding against illnesses and diseases like cancer and heart disease.

The higher CLA content in grass-fed beef can be attributed to the cow’s more natural diet of grass, which provides the nutrients necessary for the production of this beneficial fatty acid. This makes grass-fed beef a healthier choice for those concerned about their overall health and well-being.

Calorie Content

Organic grass-fed beef has fewer calories than beef from conventional grain-fed cattle due to its cleaner, lower-fat diet. This naturally leaner composition makes grass-fed beef a healthier option for those looking to manage their calories intake while still enjoying a delicious steak.

On the other hand, conventional grain-fed beef has a higher calorie content due to its higher-fat diet. This higher fat content may be appealing to some in terms of taste and texture but comes at the cost of increased calorie consumption and potentially fewer health benefits compared to grass-fed beef.

Environmental Impact: Organic vs Conventional Beef Production

Considering the environmental impacts of organic and conventional beef production, organic grass-fed beef production is generally more sustainable in terms of land use, resource efficiency, and greenhouse gas emissions.

By choosing organic grass-fed beef, consumers can support producers committed to environmental enhancement and enjoy a more eco-friendly steak option.

Land Use and Resource Efficiency

Organic grass-fed beef production is generally more sustainable in terms of land use and resource efficiency compared to conventional grain-fed beef production.

Organic steak production typically requires less land and water resources, while promoting the use of sustainable farming practices that can help preserve natural resources and reduce environmental impacts.

In contrast, conventional steak production often requires more land and water resources and does not encourage the use of sustainable farming practices. This can lead to increased environmental degradation and resource depletion, making conventional grain-fed beef a less sustainable option.

Greenhouse Gas Emissions

Greenhouse gas emissions are another critical factor to consider when comparing organic and conventional beef cattle and production methods. Organic grass-fed beef production typically has lower greenhouse gas emissions than conventional grain-fed beef production.

This lower emission rate can be attributed to the more sustainable farming practices employed in organic beef production, such as rotational grazing and reduced reliance on fossil fuel-based inputs.

In contrast, conventional beef production, with its intensive feedlot systems and high-input farming practices, generates higher greenhouse gas emissions.

Is Grass-Fed Beef Better Than Grain-Fed?

Deciding whether grass-fed beef is better than grain-fed beef ultimately comes down to personal preferences and priorities.

In terms of taste and texture, organic grass-fed beef offers a more natural, game-like flavor and chewier texture, while conventional grain-fed beef delivers a sweeter, juicier taste and more tender texture. However, from a health perspective, grass-fed beef is the clear winner due to its higher levels of omega-3 fatty acids, CLA, and lower calorie content.

Furthermore, the environmental impact of beef production should also be considered.

Organic grass-fed beef production is generally more sustainable in terms of land use, resource efficiency, and greenhouse gas emissions. By choosing grass-fed beef, consumers can support environmentally responsible producers and enjoy a more eco-friendly option.

Making an Informed Choice: Which is the Best Steak for You?

Ultimately, the decision between organic grass-fed and conventional grain-fed steak depends on your personal preferences, health concerns, and environmental considerations.

Take into account the differences in taste, texture, health benefits, and environmental impact when choosing the best steak for you.

By making an informed choice, you can enjoy a delicious and satisfying steak experience that aligns with your values and priorities.

Summary

In conclusion, both organic grass-fed and conventional grain-fed beef offer unique taste profiles, textures, and health benefits.

While grass-fed beef provides a more natural, game-like flavor, a leaner texture, and higher levels of essential nutrients, grain-fed beef offers a sweeter, juicier taste and a more tender texture.

Additionally, organic grass-fed beef production is generally more sustainable and eco-friendly compared to conventional beef production.

Ultimately, the choice between these two types of steaks will come down to personal preferences, health priorities, and environmental considerations.

But it’s also worth considering which product on your butcher’s shelves is fresher.

After all, some products sell a lot better than others and so the slower sellers in the steak area might still be good but far less fresh. In which case the better-tasting choice might technically be the one you wouldn’t immediately select.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does organic steak taste different?

Many people who have tried organic steak report that it has a full-bodied flavor with a slightly gamey taste and undertones of grass or hay, making it delicious to experienced eaters.

Organic steak is a great choice for those who want to enjoy a flavorful and unique meal. It is also a healthier option than traditional steak, as it is free of hormones and antibiotics. Organic steak is also more sustainable, as it is produced without the use of chemicals.

Is organic steak better?

Overall, organic meat does not appear to have any significantly greater nutrient density than conventional meat. Consequently, organic steak may not be superior in nutrition to conventionally produced steak.

However, there are numerous studies that have shown a significantly negative impact on human health from the consumption of products containing antibiotics and growth hormones. (source) and (source).

Is organic beef better than regular beef?

Organic beef is free from antibiotics and hormones, contains higher levels of antioxidants such as Vitamin E and A, and has higher levels of heart-healthy linolenic acid than regular beef. Though the research does not always show that organic meat is more nutrient-dense than conventional meat, USDA Certified Organic guarantees that your beef will be free of contaminants.

Organic beef is a great choice for those looking for a healthier alternative to regular beef. It is free from antibiotics and hormones, contains higher levels of antioxidants, and has higher levels of heart-healthy linolenic acid. Additionally, USDA Certified Organic guarantees that your beef will be certified organic.

But you also have to consider the various grades of beef.

So a non-organic USDA Prime steak might taste better than an organic USDA Select steak, despite the supposed health benefits of the organic item.

What are the main differences between organic grass-fed and conventional grain-fed beef?

Organic grass-fed beef differs from conventional grain-fed beef in terms of diet, living conditions, production methods, taste, texture, health benefits, and environmental impact.

The diet of organic grass-fed beef is composed of grasses, legumes, and forbs, while conventional grain-fed beef is fed a diet of grains, such as corn and soy. Organic grass-fed beef is raised in open pastures.

Are there any environmental benefits to choosing organic grass-fed beef over conventional grain-fed beef?

Yes, organic grass-fed beef production has environmental benefits due to its lower land use, resource efficiency, and reduced greenhouse gas emissions.

It is also beneficial for animal welfare, as the animals are raised in more natural conditions and are not given hormones or antibiotics.

Organic grass-fed beef is also healthier for humans, as it contains higher levels of nutrients.

What is the difference between grass-fed beef and grass-finished beef?

Grass-fed animals (forage-fed cattle) are primarily raised on pastures, with grass being the primary diet in the early years.

However, this doesn’t mean they exclusively eat grass. In fact, grass-fed cattle may well have been grain-fed for the latter part of their lives.

In contrast, grass-finished beef refers to cattle that have consumed grass for their entire life, finishing their last months on pasture.

The American Grassfed Association specifies that for beef to be considered grass-finished (forage-based diets), cattle must have continuous access to pastures and never be confined to animal feeding operations where they might be given grains.

This distinction plays a role in meat quality, with some asserting that grass-finished beef has a richer, more distinctive flavor, while grain-finished beef might be more marbled and tender.

Ultimately, whether one opts for grass-fed or grass-finished often boils down to personal preference, influenced by desired taste, nutritional considerations, and ethical values.

Brisket is arguably the holy grail of barbecue. But when you go to the store, there can be a lot of brisket choices and sizes. So, how do you pick a good brisket?

Start by picking Prime or Choice brisket. Then look out for dark purple-ish meat that has a “fat cap” at least 1/2 inch thick, and is streaked with flecks of glossy white fat. Also, look for one that isn’t significantly thinner on one side than the other, as this can cause uneven cooking.

Of course, Wagyu brisket is often an option, but it is more expensive.

The marbling is vital as it’s central to whether the brisket would be juicy, tender, and flavorful. But this is just a small part of what we’ll learn.

In the article, we’ll explore which cut of the brisket is the best, what a good brisket looks like, and which one is better: Prime or Choice.

We’ll also check out which one is ideal: The point or the flat cut. And, we’ll conclude by considering a “taboo”: whether cutting the brisket in half before smoking is OK. After all, some whole briskets are huge and might not fit as one piece in your smoker.

Let’s dive right in…

Which cut of brisket is best?

The point is the best cut in a brisket because it has more fat and is more marbled. Naturally, it is the more tender and flavorful cut. It is smaller, thicker, and more marbled than the flat, which has more connective tissue which can make it tougher.

First off, let’s back up a bit and understand what’s brisket.

Beef brisket is the chest muscle that’s found near the front legs of the steer. It’s a tough cut — it’s not tender because it’s actually muscles that are close to the legs and do receive a lot of workouts.

It’s huge and is made up of two cuts — the flat and the point, also known as the first and second cut, respectively.

They are almost always sold separately. But you can also buy the whole brisket —- in other words, the point and the flat combined. Larger briskets are great, but they are huge!

It’s known as a “full packer” or “packer” brisket. Unless you’re cooking for a large number of people, you won’t need to buy a brisket this large.

Choosing a great brisket shouldn’t be a chore, so we made an easy checklist!
• Go for the prime cut!
• Meat should be dark red, almost purple in color.
• Fat should be a clear white.
• Flat should be an inch or thicker.
• Marbling should be prominent. pic.twitter.com/LCqa7SAniy

— Brocmar Smokehouse (@BrocmarBBQ) February 2, 2021

What does a good brisket look like?

A good brisket has a dark purple-ish color, it’s floppy, and it has a fat cap; a layer of fat on one side that is at least 1/4 inch thick. The other side will also be flecked with fat. The more the fat, the more flavorful, the more tender, and the juicier it will be. 

But the grade of the beef is the first factor to check out — Choice is good, but Prime is better. Avoid Select brisket as it will naturally be lower quality.

If you’re buying a whole packer brisket — that’s the whole brisket, look for one that has a uniform and thick flat, with the flat being at least 1-inch thick at the end.

You also want to look for a brisket that has a fat cap which should be no thicker than 1 inch. 

I say no more than 1 inch because you’ll be trimming off the excess down to somewhere between 1/4 inch and 1/2 inch. So a really thick fat cap means, since you’re paying by the pound, you’ll be wasting money paying for that much fat.

The cap keeps the meat moist and traps evaporating moisture. The fat should be white and glossy.

You want to look out for brisket that’s highly marbled, a reflection of the intramuscular fat. If you look closely at the meat, you can see whether it’s well-marbled or not. It’s simply the white flecks of intramuscular fat on the cut.

Now, if you’re going to wrap your brisket a few hours in, as people like BBQ-god Aaron Franklin do, you’ll want butcher paper, not foil.

Is parchement paper the same as butcher paper? And do grocery stores sell parchment paper?

In a recent article, I said they often do. But I also explored whether butcher paper is sold at Walmart, Target, and Home Depot and whether you can use wax paper instead.

Just click the link to read it on my site.

Oh wow. Prime Barbecue if you’re ever in Knightdale is incredible. I’m not usually a brisket guy, but I am now. pic.twitter.com/1Jmtyxg5no

— Tim Buckley (@TimBuckleyWX) June 5, 2021

Is Prime or Choice brisket better?

Prime brisket is better than Choice brisket because Prime beef is the highest grade of beef. It is beef that has the highest marbling, which makes it more tender, flavorful, and juicier. But Prime is very rare. In fact, on average, about 2% of beef receives the grade “Prime.”

Prime and Choice are beef grades applied to meat by the USDA.

They are labels that indicate the quality of the meat in terms of tenderness, juiciness, and flavor. Prime is the highest of the grades. It’s indicative of meat from young cattle that have been fed well.

This is shown in how much marbling it has. This is usually more pronounced when one checks the “point” end of the brisket.

Choice is good. In fact, because of the scarcity of Prime, Choice is what is often used at BBQ restaurants. It has less marbling than Prime, as such is not quite as tender. But it will still make a fine choice.

Lots of people shop at places like Sam’s Club or Costco. And both offer a large array of meat. But who has better meat, Sam’s or Costco’s? 

Both offer USDA Prime meat in addition to Choice. In a recent article, I get into that question. But the irony is that one of those stores is cheaper than the other while one has a tendency to have fresher meat. But there is one clear winner.

Just click the link to read it on my site.

Brisket question – Point or Flat? pic.twitter.com/yhISbIJ4NP

— WOWBBQ.co.uk (@wowbbquk) June 23, 2021

Is brisket point or flat better?

The point of a brisket has more fat and is more flavorful, making it more sought after, especially for “fattier” brisket. But it does not have as much meat as the flat. The flat is usually larger than the point and has more meat, and is overall leaner.

Some folks prefer the point because it is more tender and juicier.

Both are delicious when cooked well. So, it depends on what you want. The flat has less fat. If you’re being careful about your fat intake, the flat might be the way to go. It has a more rectangular shape, so it’s a lot easier to slice it into uniform pieces.

The point is the more tender and flavorful part because it has more fat. The downside is that you won’t have as much meat. It’s great if you prefer barbecued meat sandwiches.

Is Prime Steak Worth It?

In a recent article, I explained why that’s not always true. I conducted a blind taste test of USDA Prime, Select, Angus, and grass-fed ribeye steaks. I cooked them all exactly the same at the same time, and then we judged for ourselves.

Just click the link to read it on my site and see which one tasted best!

Is it OK to cut brisket in half before smoking?

As a general rule, it is OK to cut brisket in half before smoking. Brisket is usually smoked whole. But when smoking a whole brisket, if it will not fit into the smoker, simply divide the flat and the point before smoking.

Of course, if it will fit, by all means, leave it whole.

But it makes sense to cut brisket in half if you have a whole one that is too big for your smoker. Brisket is made up of these two different muscles — the fat and the point. You’ll need a sharp knife to carefully divide the full packer into the two sub-primal cuts.

Refer to this image, but the point has a tip and then folds underneath the flat. It’s easier to see if you lay a whole brisket on the table with the fattiest side down.

Then look for a fat seam separating the two.

Start cutting into the fat seam, knowing that it curves back. Just keep cutting into that fat seam until you are left with just a thin flap of meat. Cut through that, and you now have both the point and the flat to cook separately.

Want to know which grocery store has the best steak? 

Check out a recent article where I revealed that prime beef is available in small quantities at grocers such as Wegmans and Whole Foods. You’ll get the best steak at the latter.

I also included a guide on the parts of the cow different steaks are cut from. And what makes one steak better than another.

Just click the link to read it on my site.

How to cook a perfect brisket

For starters don’t go crazy with rubs or marinades. Salt and pepper are all you really need, and be generous with both. You want that smokey, beefy flavor to come through.

For perfect brisket, cook at about 250° for about 75 minutes per pound. Oak is a great wood choice. Be careful about using only hickory or mesquite as they can result in the brisket being too smokey and the meat flavor not coming through.

Cook it fat side up in your smoker, and if it starts to look dry, spritz occasionally with a mix of apple juice and/or apple cider vinegar and water.

You’ll see a lot of sites saying fat side down. But world-renowned brisket master Aaron Franklin says fat side up. In my experience, this does result in a moister brisket because as the fat renders, it melts into the meat instead of just down into your smoker.

After about 4 hours, when the brisket reaches an internal temp of 165°-170°, wrap the brisket in butcher paper.

Continue to smoke for the right amount of time until the brisket hits an internal temperature of 195-203°F. Then take it out of the smoker for 1 hour (still wrapped).

After 1 hour, remove from the butcher paper and slice it against the grain on the flat side. Always use a serrated knife. If you have a whole packer with both the flat and the point, keep slicing that way until you get to the point. The grain goes in different directions from the point to the flat.

So then just turn the brisket 90 degrees and continue to slice it against the grain.

Conclusion 

In this article, we looked at which cut of the brisket is the best and which one is better: Prime or Choice grade brisket.

We also checked out which one is ideal: Point or Flat, and what a good brisket looks like.  And, we wrapped things up by considering if it is cool to cut brisket in half before smoking.

Ultimately the best brisket is going to be Wagyu beef, the point cut, and USDA Prime. If you can find grass-fed; even better! In most cases, you can find a great brisket right at your local grocery store. But if you have a local butcher; even better!

Ready to smoke a perfect brisket every time?

Check out this recent article on my other website that walks you through the brisket smoking process step-by-step. Just click that link to read it on my site.

---

Photos that require attribution:

Whole brisket by Brett Spangler and Brisket by Rebecca Siegel are licensed under CC2.0 and were cropped, edited, and had a text overlay added.

The sight and aroma of a freshly grilled steak can automatically activate one’s taste buds. But now and then, you happen on a tough one that’s chewy and not very appetizing. It makes you wonder how do I make steak more tender?

Make steak more tender by buying USDA Prime or Choice beef. Dry-aged and/or grass-fed are also good options. Then beat the steak with a mallet, adding salt before cooking. Slow-cook extra tough cuts of beef, then allow it to rest for 5 minutes after it’s been cooked and slice against the grain.

In this article, we’ll explore 4 related themes:

• Why is my steak tough and chewy
• What is a good tenderizer?
• Does beef get more tender the longer it is cooked?
• 11 simple tips to make steak more tender

Making flavorful and tender steak is an art form. But it doesn’t have to be a mystery or something that just happens occasionally and seemingly for no reason. You can master the art of a perfect steak every time!

Let the fun begin…

11 Tips on How to Make Steak More Tender

1. Pick the most tender cut in your budget

These include filet mignon, top sirloin, New York strip steak, and rib eye.

This is arguably the most important tip. It starts with the cut. You want to buy the best part of the bull that you can afford. The reality is that not all parts of a bull are created equal. Interesting, right?

So, get a part that’s got fat and is highly marbled because both indicate tender steak. The rib-eye is the most tender and flavorful and is naturally the most expensive.

But there are other parts of the steer that are good, too. Even if you’re on a budget, some may just need a little preparation to bring out the best in them.

But get started with the most tender part.

And on the flipside, avoid buying a tough cut of meat, or at least plan to slow cook them until tender. Those cuts of beef include:

• Flank steak
• Skirt steak
• Chuck steak

2. Buy USDA Prime or Choice and not Select

For the most tender steak, you want to choose the best grades of beef. It’s a no-brainer, right? And, Prime or Choice is the way to go. Ignore Select.

Prime is what you’d often get at upscale restaurants. It’s the best of the best. In fact, less than 3% of meat makes this grade. It’s from young, well-fed cattle. Its fat and marbling content is high.

Choice is exceptional quality meat, too. But, its fat and marbling are not as rich as Prime. About 53% of consumable beef falls into this category, and it’s the most available grade you’d find in grocery stores.

Is Prime steak worth it? 

In a recent article of mine, I did a “study” where I found that USDA Choice Grass-Fed Steaks taste better than USDA Prime. Despite the differences between certified Angus USDA Choice and regular USDA Choice and USDA Prime, the differences weren’t substantial enough to warrant a price difference.

Just click the link to read it on my site.

3. Buy dry-aged or grass-fed when possible

Dry-aged beef is more tender and flavorful. And grass-fed, while a tad leaner, is also going to be more flavorful.

That’s why you’d want to get them when possible. But, you might be wondering: What the heck is “dry-age?” As the name suggests, it’s meat that’s been aged for some time before it’s cooked or roasted.

It’s often aged for between 7 days and up to 30 days.

The drying draws out the moisture, and some enzymes are released. They help in further breaking down the meat, making it flavorful and tender. It’s often expensive and rare as most stores don’t sell it. Dry-aging essentially helps improve the steak’s texture and taste.

But don’t worry about food safety. The dry-aging happens in a temperature and humidity-controlled aging cooler.

Grass-fed, as the name implies, refers to cattle that have been fed a diet of grass rather than grain. Many ranchers feed their cattle corn and other grain feed as it’s inexpensive. To have cattle that roam freely eating grass just costs more money.

But ultimately, cows (like most animals) weren’t designed to eat corn and their diet and the flavor of the meat, benefit greatly from a natural diet of just eating grass.

An overnight marinade of this steak yields incredibly tender results, but a 30-minute steep is sufficient to infuse the meat with the fruity flavor of the chiles. https://t.co/rV5Ok5e4UV

— The New York Times (@nytimes) May 9, 2021

4. Beat the steak with a mallet

Beating the steak with a mallet would make it more tender.

But I wouldn’t do this with a high-quality steak. No, this is better when done to a cheaper cut of beef such as flank or tri-tip.

Because meat hammers are heavy, you want to be careful that you don’t beat it too much so that it doesn’t become too soft or mushy. Beating it with a mallet breaks down the muscle fiber making it more tender.

You could place the steak between two plastic sheets before you do.

5. Don’t overdo the marinade – it adds flavor more than tenderness

Marinating is believed to be helpful when you want to make steak more tender.

But if you’re starting with a dry-aged ribeye, you’ve already got a great-tasting steak. It doesn’t need more flavor, and a marinade might cover up that great taste. A steak like that just needs salt, pepper, and a hot grill.

Extra moisture is introduced into the steak while it sits in the marinade. It’s this moisture that makes it softer and more flavorful. So yes, if you have tri-tip, it could benefit from a good marinade.

But feel free to skip the marinade when you have high-quality cuts of beef.

6. Take the meat out of refrigeration for 30 minutes before cooking

It’s vital to bring steak to room temperature before cooking.

At the risk of stating the obvious, while it’s in the fridge, it’s cold. You want it pretty close to its natural state before you start cooking it.

If not, you could have a situation where the outer part could burn while the inside is still cold! But you don’t want to leave it outside for more than 30 minutes. The food temperature danger zone is between 40° F and 140° F.

So once something goes into that range, the danger of food-borne illness begins to increase. But most foods are safe outside of refrigeration for up to 2 hours.

(source)

Secret to tender steak: 1/2tsp sea salt flakes either side & rest for 15mins per 1/4in of thickness. #steaktips pic.twitter.com/ukfWFi6Lar

— Richard Coombs (@Edenleepsychbus) August 24, 2014

7. Do add salt before cooking – it removes moisture

Salted meat, as you know, tastes better than unsalted meat.

Why? When meat is salted, the salt changes the molecular structure of the protein. In this state, the steak can absorb more water. So, it softens and becomes juicier and tastier than an unsalted one.

This is why Chefs often salt steak before cooking. The salt draws out the moisture, making the flavor more concentrated. Just pay attention to the marinade you’re using, as if it contains a lot of soy sauce, you won’t need to add a lot of salt since that soy sauce is already salty.

8. The tougher the beef, the lower temp and the longer time it should cook (flank, round, hanger)

Tough beef needs time to cook.

It makes sense, right? But, the last thing you want to do is cook it at a high temperature. That would serve to dry it up and toughen it further.

It’s better to “slow-cook” it.

This helps ensure that the beef is evenly cooked without any drastic moisture loss. 160 degrees F or even 190 degrees F is a good temp to aim for. Slow cooking might seem counterintuitive, but it’s a proven method used by pros.

But again, don’t slow cook that dry-aged ribeye. Slow cook roasts, brisket, and tougher cuts of beef such as London broil, flank, and round steak.

9. Cook the meat as rare as you can stand it – the more it cooks, the tougher it gets

Just as we learned in the paragraph above, cooking meat for a long time has to be done in a particular mode.

So rare is good.

It’s like the sweet spot because if you undercook, the texture and taste will not come out, and if you overcook, you’ve probably wasted money! So, you want to cook it as rare as you can stand it so that you don’t cook it to a point where it tastes like leather!

Don’t forget to slice against the grain when cutting London broil steak. #recipe #delicious https://t.co/hIbkcKyHvN pic.twitter.com/CHV6G22NFt

— Todd Jeskulski (@SkiTeamRealtor) October 25, 2019

10. Allow the steak to sit once cooked, for 5 minutes

It’s tempting to want to rush ahead and start cutting the steak after you’ve cooked it.

I understand. But it’s better to let it rest for a while. Rest? Yes. Allow the steak to sit at least for 5 minutes. Why would I do that? (That’s what you’re thinking, right?). That’s what the pros do.

They do it because while it rests, the steak can now redistribute the juice that has been constricted while it was being cooked. If you were to ignore the “rest phase”, you’d notice that the juice slips out, and the final product becomes dry and tough.

The ideal place to let it rest is inside a microwave that isn’t running.

This allows it to sit, at room temp, but away from any breezes from nearby ceiling fans, and away from any flies that may be buzzing around your house.

11. Slice the steak against the grain 

First off, what’s the grain?

It’s vital to know if you’re going to slice against it. The grain refers to the direction of the muscle fibers. It’s important to cut against it because it’s not simply the cut of the beef that makes it tender.

If you look closely at a steak, you will see lines running from one direction to the other.

So slicing against the grain simply means to slice it at a 90° angle from the direction of those lines. This helps break up those muscle fibers and ensures you aren’t trying to chew across a long strand of connective tissue.

Which grocery store has the best steak?

After all, as I mentioned above, WHERE you buy your beef makes a big difference in the quality and can definitely affect how tender the finished product is.

In a recent article, I looked at the quality of beef at several stores and which ones tend to have the best options in terms of things like USDA Prime, dry-aged, or grass-fed. And I end with my pick of the best options.

Just click the link to read it on my site.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is my steak tough and chewy?

Steak can be chewy if it is overcooked, or the cut was too lean and lacked the appropriate amount of fat. But it’s also important to choose the right cut of beef for the cooking method as certain steaks such as flank will be more tender if slow-cooked.

The cut of beef, how fresh it is, the marbling on it, how it was prepared, and whether it was cut with or against the grain are all factors that could account for why steak is tough and chewy.

Some parts of the cow are often tougher than the others and are often not as expensive as the more tender parts.

The tender parts are rich in fat and marbling. These two are what make steak tender and succulent. Conversely, lean steak cuts with little to no fat or marbling are tough and chewy.

So there’s a need to prep them before cooking or roasting to bring out their flavor and tenderness.

The tough part is usually the part that’s been exercised a lot — as it walks around, for example. It follows that steak from older cows would be tougher than that from younger ones.

The parts that have not been affected much by the exercises and which are highly marbled are the ones that are tender and flavorful.

Say you’ve got tough steak, what can you do about it? No worries. There are tons of tenderizers. Let’s meet them in the next section.

@TheVillageButch Your rib eye steak. Seasoned with garlic, paprika, black pepper and lemon juice. Delicious and tender. Thank you. pic.twitter.com/kOiWRuA2jC

— 🕷🕷🕸Maureen McCollum🕸🕷🕷 (@Mccoll131) January 28, 2017

What is a good steak tenderizer?

To make a steak more tender, papaya, pineapple, yogurt, lemon juice, or a marinade can all help. Additionally, using a mallet to pound the steak, or scoring the steak before cooking can help. Then allow to rest for 5 minutes after cooking, and then slice against the grain.

Let’s check out a couple of these tenderizing methods.

Beat it

No, I don’t mean the Michael Jackson song. I meant to beat the meat. Using a meat mallet to beat meat is one of the ways to tenderize it. It makes sense, right? The meat is tough, and it has to be beaten into shape.

It’s effective, but don’t overdo it.

The meat could turn into mush! So, there’s a need to be gentle. Ultimately, your goal is to break down some of the tough fibrous connective tissue inside the steak.

Marinate 

Marinating the meat is another great way to tenderize tougher and/or cheaper cuts of beef, and you’ve got two options.

You could marinate in acid or enzymes. You could make a marinade with yogurt, vinegar, lime juice, or buttermilk.

They all contain acid, which helps break down tough protein. Ideally, leave the meat in the marinade for at least 30 minutes up to 2 hours max. This is because you don’t want it to be too soft or mushy.

Acids can easily and quickly break down the protein structure of meat! That’s how things like ceviche can be “cooked” just by soaking in lime juice.

Would beef get more tender if you just cooked it for a longer time? That’s what we’ll explore next.

Does beef get more tender the longer you cook it?

Beef does not necessarily get more tender the longer it’s cooked. The best cuts for slow cooking are chuck, shoulder, skirt, brisket, and oxtail. Steaks such as ribeye, New York, or filet mignon will all dry up and become tough if overcooked.

So it is possible to cook beef for a long time, and it would still end up dry and tough, not tender.

Beef, like other meats, is made up of muscles, connective tissues, and fat. What we often see (and eat) is the muscle. Fat usually serves as a covering over the muscles and as marbling between muscle fibers.

It’s the marbled fat that makes the beef succulent and tender. You know that muscles (meat in this case) become stronger the more they are exercised. So, the part that’s highly exercised is usually tough.

In other words, the part of the steer in question is a factor in whether it’s tough or tender. Another is the age of the steer; the older, the tougher the beef.

But of course, aside from buying meat from reputable places, we have no way of knowing how old the cow was before slaughter. So let’s focus on what we can control.

If you’re looking to get tender beef, cooking it for a long time is not the answer across the board.

And the most marbled cuts all benefit from cooking for a relatively short period of time at a high temperature. That’s why steakhouses such as Ruth’s Chris cook their steaks in an 1800-degree broiler and then serve it on a plate heated to 500° F.

Trust me, if you go slow and low on something like a USDA Prime dry-aged rib eye, you’ll destroy the flavor and tenderness of that great steak.

Conclusion

In the article, we looked at why steak can be tough and chewy.

Then, we checked out some good steak tenderizers and explored what happens to meat when it’s cooked for long. Does it automatically become tender, or are there some nuances to note?

Turns out, longer doesn’t necessarily translate to more tender. We moved on to look at 11 simple tips for making steak more tender.

Going to the grocery store’s meat department can be overwhelming. There are so many choices in the beef section alone with lots of different products and best-by dates. So, how can you tell good quality beef?

Identify good quality beef by looking for a bright red color, little to no pooling of blood in the package, no gray spots on the meat, and ensuring the sell-by date is at least 1-2 days away. Then look for a USDA label of either Choice or Prime, avoiding Select, which is lower quality.

Read on because we will check out most of these factors and related themes around how to select good quality beef.

In this article, we’ll explore the characteristics of quality meat. We’ll check out the best quality grade of meat. We’ll consider whether Angus trumps Prime.

And we’ll find out if Angus is better than Wagyu. We’ll wrap things up by considering whether the quality of meat matters.

Let’s get into it.

What are the characteristics of quality meat?

The characteristics of good quality meat include a bright red color, little to no smell, smooth, clean cuts on steaks with no jagged edges, a high level of marbling, a glistening on the surface of the meat with no discolored spots. 

Let’s check out a couple of these factors. Shall we?

1. The color of the meat

We should be looking at the color first. After all, that’s the first thing you’ll notice. Quality beef can be red or maybe a little purple, but not brown.

It becomes brownish when it’s been exposed to oxygen. So, while not necessarily spoiled, brown meat is definitely not as fresh.

Of course, it also depends on the kind of meat we’re talking about, right?

Game meat should be brown, while pork should be greyish pink. Fresh meat from a lamb is usually a vibrant red. Poultry can be grey-white or blue-white to dull red.

2. The smell of the meat

This is something we can all easily relate to.

Most things that smell funny repel us, right? It’s a good guide when choosing meat. We often do this instinctively. We smell some things before we buy or consume them.

Quality meat doesn’t have the most pleasing smell in the world, but it never smells funny (read: pungent or sour).

Interestingly, how it’s perceived varies from person to person.

To some people, the smell seems acidic. To others, it’s simply neutral. But fresh meat never smells like something rotten.

3. The quantity of its marbling

Marbling is a fancy word for fat that’s interspersed throughout the meat.

We’ll dwell on it a bit because it’s arguably the most vital factor in determining the quality of meat. It’s the main factor that makes meat juicy, tender, and flavorful. It’s one of the things pros look out for.

You should, too.

Marbling is reflected in the white flecks and streaks of fat in and all over the meat. It’s intramuscular fat and is more common in red meat. It’s a function of the diet and the breed of the cattle.

Grain-fed animals have more marbling than those fed on corn.

If the meat you’re considering has little to no marbling, it’s going to end up tough and chewy unless you know some special ways to prepare it. This is often time-consuming.

So, it’s not a route I advise taking. If you want it leaner, just trim a little of the excess fat off at home before cooking. 

But remember that much of that fat will render (i.e., melt) when cooking. And if you cook it on the grill, much of that fat will just drip through the grates.

It’s best to pick meat that’s highly marbled from the get-go. But exterior fat doesn’t count when marbling is being considered.

By the way, it’s called marbling because the pattern does look like marble.

4. The texture of the meat

Quality meat is dry, dense, and firm. It’s tightly packed.

Even though the animal is dead, the meat has a high level of cohesion. It’s “still together.” If the meat you’re checking out seems as if it’s going to fall apart at any moment, you might want to be cautious about buying it. The quality is poor, or it’s been handled poorly while in transit.

Sam’s Club or Costco, which one has better meat? 

Get the lowdown in a recent article of mine. I compared both stores’ meat quality. I spoke about whether Sam’s Club’s meat is truly from China. I even revealed which one has the better brisket.

Just click the link to read it on my site.

Only the best at Georges, we use prime grade beef. 🏅 pic.twitter.com/o6Ssn3Ng8x

— Georges French Bistro (@georgesict) October 17, 2019

What is the best quality grade of beef?

Prime is the best quality grade of beef. It’s the highest-ranking selection out of 8 grades devised by the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA). Grass-fed beef is generally preferred over grain-fed, and grass-fed can also be Prime.

Some of the criteria used by the USDA in its evaluation are the degree of marbling the meat has and the age of the animal from which it has been cut.

On its website, it states that it grades beef in two ways.

One, quality grades. Second, yield grades. The former refers to how tasty, juicy, and flavorful the meat would be, while the latter is an estimate of the amount of usable meat that would be left on the steer after it’s been butchered.

Prime is the best quality because it’s cut from young, well-fed cattle and is highly marbled. So, the taste is awesome. It’s also great for dry aging.

So, you can broil, grill, or roast it, and if you know how, it’ll come out tender and flavorful.

If you’d like to take a deep dive into beef grading, then check out a recent article where I got into whether Prime is worth it. I shared some strange truths about Angus and Prime (a must-read). And I even shared the result of a taste challenge that I conducted.

Just click the link to read it on my site.

The below shows a list of all 8 grades of beef based on evaluation by the USDA.

1. U.S. Prime
2. U.S. Choice
3. U.S. Select
4. U.S. Standard
5. U.S. Commercial
6. U.S. Utility
7. U.S. Cutter
8. U.S. Canner

Prime Angus beef https://t.co/WPH0FC540k pic.twitter.com/W7IVG5GcYX

— kazu (@kazuak) January 20, 2021

Is Angus better than Prime?

It’s not appropriate to compare Prime and Angus. Prime is a grade of beef from the USDA based on certain characteristics, while Angus is a breed of cattle. Angus can be Prime, but it could also be Choice or Select too.

The reality is that Angus can be great or simply okay.

After all, a Prime steak that isn’t Angus is likely going to be better than a Select steak that is Angus. The feeding, whether an animal was fed hormones or antibiotics, are all factors that impact its quality.

Angus is a marketing tool, it’s not necessarily indicative of a better quality of meat.

Angus is a breed that was native to Scotland.  But they are being raised in America now. Angus is a breed that’s strong and has a high yield relative to other breeds. They can withstand harsh winters and intense summers.

This sturdy characteristic is reflected in the quality of their meat.

The female can grow up to 550 pounds, the male, 850 pounds. The meat is well-marbled and delicious. Restaurants often charge a higher price because of their superior quality.

Naturally, the beef from Angus is usually labeled Prime.

In a nutshell, Angus is the name of a breed of cattle, while Prime is a designation for the highest cut of beef.

Thin sliced beef. Wagyu vs. Angus #beef pic.twitter.com/Yq679Jdadv

— Brad Hastings (@bhast50) June 22, 2016

Which is better, Angus or Wagyu?

Wagyu is better than Angus. “Angus” and “Wagyu” are the names of 2 breeds of cow. Wagyu is regarded as the highest quality beef. It’s highly marbled and more tender than most other breeds.

Angus is originally from Scotland, while Wagyu is originally from Japan. But both are raised in many places now, including the US.

Just as in other species, different breeds show variations. Wagyu is more tender and flavorful, and healthier to boot.

Wagyu cows are raised (prior to slaughter) for a longer time than Angus. This helps in increasing the degree of marbling present in the meat. Some are fed up to 600 days. Compare that to the 250 days on average for Angus and other breeds.

This begs the question: Why not just feed Angus longer, too? 

It’s been tested. It doesn’t increase the marbling, it increases the yield, but the marbling is not positively impacted. It’s simply a question of genetics.

Remember that earlier we saw that Angus is one of the best breeds. Wagyu is the creme de la creme of cattle breeds, and it shows in its quality and price.

Great. But you can’t necessarily find Wagyu everywhere. So, which grocery stores have the best steak?

That’s what I looked at in a recent article. In it, I shared an interesting graphic showing all the different cuts of meat from cows and exactly where they come from.

But I explained what makes one type of steak better than another. And I revealed the stores where you can get the best steak.

Just click the link to read it on my site.

Beef producers work hard to produce high quality cattle. It is encouraging to hear how the meat industry works hard to utilize the meat as best they can, & create the best eating experience for customers. Thanks Chef Cameron for sharing your passion ⁦@CanadianBeef⁩ pic.twitter.com/bMbrEtp4r2

— Jaclyn Horenberg (@JaclynHorenberg) December 15, 2019

Does the quality of meat matter?

The quality of meat matters because our enjoyment and health are impacted by the quality of everything we ingest. Low-quality meat will not taste as good and will likely have a less appealing texture as well. Feeling dissatisfied with food can also lead to overeating.

(source)

The health of the general public is the key reason why the quality of meat matters. So, how animals are raised is a vital issue in the quest to ensure that no harmful meat is sold.

But the reality is that there’s a balance between what we as consumers want and what producers want.

We would like high-quality meat produced under the most hygienic conditions sold at relatively low prices. The reality is that the more producers put in place measures to ensure high-quality meat, the higher their cost structure.

And the average consumer doesn’t always know enough to gauge quality meat vs. mediocre quality meat.

But thankfully, the USDA is a vital factor in ensuring that there are regulations in place to ensure that quality (delicious and healthy) meat is being produced.

But what about meat from China? After all, Chinese products have had safety concerns for quite a while.

Is it true that Aldi’s meat comes from China? In a recent article, I answered the question. I also spoke about the kind of meat it has on offer and the quality of the meat it sells. And I showed why its meat is so cheap.

Just click the link to read it on my site.

Conclusion 

In this article, we explored the characteristics of quality meat. We checked out the best quality grade of beef.  We also considered whether Angus trumps Prime. And we found out if Angus is better than Wagyu.

We wrapped things up by considering whether the quality of meat matters.

---

Image by Székely Tamás from Pixabay

One of the secrets to cooking great steaks is to know how to cook them and how to pick a good one. And steaks with the most connective tissue often end up rubbery and chewy. So in case you want to avoid them, what steaks have the most connective tissue?

The steaks with the most connective tissue include round steaks, tri-tip steak, chuck steaks, flank steak, and London broil. But of all of those, steaks from the chuck area have the most connective tissue. 

The chuck area is the cow’s entire shoulder region.

The reason it’s the cut with the most connective tissue is that it’s linked to the legs, which receive a lot of exercise. So, the muscles are strong but not tender.

As the cow moves around, the chuck gets stronger and tougher.

In the article, we’ll explore which steaks have the most connective tissue and which ones are the most tender. But we’ll also look at how to cook a steak with a lot of connective tissue so it is the most tender it can be.

Let’s get into it.

Does ribeye have connective tissue?

Ribeye does have connective tissue, but not as much as many other types of steak. Steak is essentially muscle-bound by connective tissue. Ribeye is tender as the muscles in that area have less connective tissue and get used less.

First off, what is connective tissue?

It is an integral component of steak. As the name suggests, it connects. Some types of connective tissue connect muscles to bones and ligaments, while others connect bones to bones.

There’s another variant known as silverskin, which covers the whole muscles. And, lastly, a type that covers each fiber. It’s invisible.

Connective tissue is made up of collagen membranes, tendons, and ligaments. 

The two main types of connective tissues are collagen and elastin. Now, meat is a mix of muscles, fat, water, and connective tissues.

It follows that the ribeye must have connective tissues that connect it to bones and ligaments. The ribeye is 3 different muscles: longissimus dorsi, complexus, and spinalis.

So, it has connective tissue that links it to bones and ligaments.

But it doesn’t have as much connective tissue as the chuck and the legs. Because these parts are used a lot, they are tough and can make for a chewy steak.

By comparison, the meat in the ribeye is tender, seeing as that area of the cow is not used as much.

But are all steaks chewy?

The answer, which I get into in a recent article, is, of course, no. In it, I shared the kind of steaks that aren’t chewy and how to cook ANY steak, so it’s not chewy.

But I also looked at whether steak gets more tender the longer you cook it and which ones you’ll destroy by overcooking.

Just click the link to read it on my site.

Chuck Steak.
AKA Braising Or Casserole Steak. Located in the Neck, This Cut Contains Muscle, Fat and Connective Tissue. When Slow Cooked, Braising Is Easiest, The Collagens Breakdown Into A Soft Gelatin.
With This Cut 3-4 Hours @ No Higher Than 160F or 70C pic.twitter.com/dqRZKguGhc

— Beefy Allan 🍖🍔 (@Weibman3465) April 2, 2019

How do you break down the connective tissue in steak?

Break down connective tissues in steaks by using an acidic marinade, cooking for a long time at a low temperature, or using a meat mallet to tenderize the steak before cooking.

Let’s check out these methods in greater detail.

Chemical methods

Marinating the steak is one of the methods for breaking down the connective tissue. It’s best to have the steak in contact with the marinade. That way, the enzymes can work on it.

Wine and lemon juice are great examples.

The acids in them help break down. Some fruits are also effective; the enzymes they contain work on the tissue. Pawpaw, pineapple, and kiwifruit are awesome.

Mechanical methods

The idea is to break the steak into smaller pieces which naturally breaks down the connective tissue. A meat mallet can be used to beat the steak into submission.

A needler can also be used. It’s a machine that makes fine cuts all over the meat or makes pincushions of it.

You can also cut the steak up into fine cubes.

Cooking methods 

Cook using moist heat at a low temperature and for a long period.

The heat gradually transforms (breaks down) the collagen (connective tissue) into gelatin, which is soft and flavorful. This method is ideal if the cut of the meat is tough.

A tender cut, on the other hand, can be cooked more rapidly, with dry heat, and at a high temperature. It has fewer connective tissues, so the long, slow cooking is unnecessary and would even be counterproductive.

In addition to learning how to break down connective tissue, it’s smart to know the least chewy steak.

You’re in luck because that’s what I looked at in a recent article of mine.

Are all steaks chewy? Are leaner steaks tougher than fatty steak? Can any steak be cooked to be tender? These and a few more are the questions I got into.

Just click the link to read it on my site.

When cooking steak, temperature matters. At 125 degrees a steak is considered rare. When it gets to 160 degrees it is well done. pic.twitter.com/oCqhVF85P1

— Freddy’s Steak House (@FreddySteak) December 4, 2019

At what temp does connective tissue break down?

Connective tissue begins to break down at 160 degrees Fahrenheit. At this point, the collagen begins to turn into rich, liquid gelatin. The breakdown is essentially a process of liquefying collagen. This is when the steak gets tender and flavorful. 

The conversion of collagen into gelatin starts at 120 degrees Fahrenheit and is heightened at 140 degrees, but it’s at 160 degrees and above that it reaches its peak.

At 120 degrees, the steak begins to turn pinkish, but it’s not reached the safe minimum temperature. At 140, the denaturing proper starts, the steak morphs from light pink to brownish grey. At this point, it is medium-rare. But it’s at 160 degrees that the collagen starts dissolving.

It’s fully dissolved at 180 degrees.

As we have seen, the conversion is a function of the temperature and how long the steak is cooked.

Technically, the conversion process is referred to as the denaturing of collagen. The connective tissues are being changed at the molecular level by the heat that is being applied.

Enzymes known as Calpains are also at work. They are responsible for producing an aging effect during cooking and become active between 80- and 105-degrees Fahrenheit.

@MuscleFoodUK #musclefood steak with lemon juice & chilli, with poached egg & asparagus 😍 pic.twitter.com/Oo8cbeetEr

— C 💙 (@ChloeBarbie) January 29, 2014

What breaks down connective tissue in steaks?

Moist heat, acids, and enzymes help in the breakdown of connective tissue in steak. Connective tissues are made up of collagen and elastin (gristle). Elastin is not responsive to heat, so consequently, it should be removed before cooking starts. Collagen, on the other hand, responds to heat. 

At a certain temperature, its denaturing is triggered and occurs at higher temperature levels and over time.

Acids such as those in vinegar and lemon juice. Alcohol is also helpful because the meat is soluble in it. Beer and wine are excellent at tenderizing the steak through the contribution of tannins.

Enzymes help accelerate the cellular reactions and attack the protein networks of tough meat. Ginger and Papaya are examples of effective marinades that facilitate enzymatic marination.

But even if acids and enzymes are not available, slow cooking in moist heat over a long time would gradually break down the connective tissue in steak.

But how do you make a steak with a lot of connective tissue more tender?

I answered that in a recent article where I explained why steak is tough and chewy and what is a good steak tenderizer. I even cover what to do on a steak you’ve already cooked!

Just click the link to read it on my site.

What steaks have the least connective tissue?

Steak from the upper part of a cow that hasn’t received a lot of muscular activity has the least connective tissue, such as the tenderloin, top sirloin, ribeye, T-bone, and porterhouse steaks.

They are not used to assist the cow in walking and thus are not as tough, resulting in a tender and flavorful taste.

Unfortunately, these parts constitute less than 10% of the cow! This is why they are expensive. That’s in addition to the fact that they are delectable. They are of high quality and are rare. So, the law of demand and supply comes to play.

The best steak is rare. That’s the honest truth, no matter what my wife says. So, which grocery store has the best steaks?

In a recent article of mine, I revealed the answer. I also shared what makes one type of steak better than another. And I offered a guide on how to pick the best steak.

Just click the link to read it on my site.

Conclusion

In the article, we learned about the steak with the most connective tissue and found out whether ribeye has connective tissue.

Then, we checked out how to break down the connective tissue in steak. We also explored at what temperature connective tissue breaks down and what breaks it down.

Lastly, we wrapped things up by looking at what steaks have the least connective tissue.

Steaks are definitely one of the delicacies most people love. But there are a lot of different cuts to choose from when it comes to buying steaks, with some being less tender than others. So are all steaks chewy?

Not all steaks are chewy, and many are tender and flavorful. The steaks that come from the parts of the cow that get used a lot, often leaner muscles, tend to be tough and chewy, while parts such as the loin are not chewy at all if prepared correctly.

In this article, we’ll explore what kind of steak isn’t chewy, how to cook steak that is not chewy, and we’ll find out if steak gets more tender the longer it is cooked.

We’ll also look at whether steak gets more tender if it is boiled and conclude with why grilled steak could be tough AND how to fix it.

Let’s dive right in…

What kind of steak isn’t chewy?

The steaks that are the least chewy and most tender include the tenderloin where the filet mignon comes from, the rib area where ribeye and prime rib come from, and the short loin area where the New York strip comes from.

And all of those come from the midsection of the cow.

Not surprisingly, these aren’t that close to the front legs or the back legs. So in walking endlessly in fields, as cows do, they aren’t the muscles getting used the most.

So naturally, steaks from those areas are the most tender.

The parts of the cow that get exercised a lot, such as near the legs, resulting in tough cuts that would most likely end up being chewy.

Those potentially chewy cuts include:

• Round
• Flank
• Shank
• Chuck
• Brisket
• London broil

But what if you already have a steak ready to cook that is one of those on that list? Can you make a chewy steak more tender?

To know how to make steak more tender, check out a recent article of mine where I shared 11 simple tips. Get started by buying USDA Prime or Choice beef. Dry-age or grass-fed are also excellent options. There’s even a way to make a steak you’ve already cooked a little more tender!

Just click the link to read it on my site.

@joesbutchershop not sure I could cook this flat iron steak any better, even used the store-brand marinade. Unfortunately, it’s tough and chewy. Disappointing and not typical from you guys. pic.twitter.com/wE1GjQzCaf

— Ben Johnson (@SpartanBJ) September 23, 2018

How do I cook a steak so it’s not chewy?

To minimize chewiness in a steak when cooking, apply salt to the steak for an hour before cooking and slice it against the grain about 5 minutes after removing it from the heat. But for tough cuts, cook it low and slow, marinate it, beat it with a mallet before cooking, or braise the meat.

Let’s check out a couple of these methods.

Cook Low and Slow

Heat is probably the most effective tenderizer.

If you cook the steak long enough, the collagen, which is a part of the connective tissues that makes it tough and chewy, would be broken down into gelatin, which is soft and jiggly. Ideally, this happens between 160 and 200 F.

This would take a long time. So, you’ll need to be patient. I bet you would forget the long hours once the aroma starts wafting around the house.

Beat the Meat

Meat is essentially made up of muscle fibers that have been toughened through use.

One of the effective ways to end up with a not chewy steak is to simply beat the meat into submission before you start cooking it.

Actually, you don’t have to expend too much energy if you use a mallet. It would help break down the fibers, making it a lot easier to cook.

Braising 

Braising is a moist-heat cooking method where you ensure the meat is immersed in liquid and is left at a gentle simmer until the collagen is broken down.

Last dinner before break is over. I spent wayyyyy too much money cooking but I cooked 3 new meals and baked 3 new desserts. My greenbeans were on point, the beef tenderloin was cooked to temp but looks overcooked and used my instant pot for the sweet potatoes. pic.twitter.com/FhqcNeu4Ng

— Adrianne Robertson (@Ms_Robertson84) January 4, 2021

Does steak get more tender the longer you cook it?

Not every steak gets more tender from being cooked longer. Tenderloin, ribeye, or New York strip would all get tough and dry if overcooked. But cuts such as brisket, chuck, flank, or round can be made more tender if cooked low and slow for a longer period.

And of course, the most classic example of slow and low would be brisket.

What do I mean by slow and low? Well, if I’m grilling a ribeye, I want my grill about as hot as I can get it. I have a Traeger Ironwood 650 and love it. But it only goes up to 500° F.

So I want to cook that ribeye at that high temperature for as short a period of time as needed for the internal temperature to get to the right temp.

Not sure what internal temp is best? Here’s a guide.

Doneness	Perfect Internal Temp	Color of the meat inside
Rare	125° F 52° C	The Center of the meat is cool and red
Medium-Rare	135° F 57° C	The Center is still red but now warm
Medium	145° F 63° C	The center is pink and warm
Medium-Well	150° F 66° C	The center is now only slightly pink
Well Done	160° F 71° C	Almost no pink
Brisket	203°F 95° C	Perfect

And to check that internal temp, you’ll need a great meat thermometer like this one on Amazon. I use this one too and it’s great. And it’s not just for meat and poultry. It works great to check the oil for deep frying, making candy, and a host of other things too.

But for slow and low, I don’t want my grill (or pan or oven) anywhere near as hot as 500.

No, I might want it closer to 275° F. Then, I may want to cook it for hours. Brisket for sure needs anywhere from 8 hours to 14 hours depending on the size of the brisket and the temp of the grill (some may go down to 225° F).

So, it makes sense that a different cut that’s tough may need to be cooked for a long time before it can become tender.

In fact, this is actually the case if you’re cooking tough cuts such as brisket, chuck, rump, flank, and round.

But, it’s good to note that even when the steak requires to be cooked for a long time, slow and low is the way to go, as it ensures that the meat is evenly exposed to the heat.

If the temperature is too high, the steak will be dry tough!

It was a perfect 130° through the center and there was no grey ring of overcooked meat around the edges. Most people’s tenderloin comes out looking like this: pic.twitter.com/ESXMKkutyE

— Dan Brian: Food Eater (@DanielBrian) July 11, 2021

Does boiling steak make it tender?

Certain tougher cuts of beef such as chuck or round will become more tender when boiled or braised. The steak is being exposed to moisture and heat, naturally, the collagen is being broken down, which is what makes a steak tough.

Boiling or braising can result in tender steak. But, it has to be done right. A gentle simmer is a way to go rather than a full boil. If the heat is too much, the reverse might be the result!

Again, those tougher cuts which could be successfully boiled or braised are:

• Round
• Flank
• Shank
• Chuck
• Brisket
• London broil

Elastin and collagen are connective tissue muscles that hold the meat together.

Both are proteins that break down when exposed to heat. So, boiling steak makes it tender. But, it can be overdone.  You can undercook, which is dangerous for one’s health. And, you can also overcook the steak.

So, when you’re boiling, you want a “slow-and-steady” approach rather than boiling the steak at full blast. 

That said, boiling is probably inappropriate for premium cuts seeing as they’re naturally tender. But it is okay for tough cuts such as the chuck, brisket, and rump.

Want to know which grocery store has the best steak? 

After all, even the best cuts of beef could be chewy if the quality of the meat was poor. Check out a recent article where I compared the quality at several grocers and came up with a clear winner.

I also included a guide on the parts of the cow different steaks are cut from. And what makes one steak better than another.

Just click the link to read it on my site.

Mojo beef with grilled onions from the other day. Some don’t like flank steak because it can be tough, but if you like marinated meats, it’s a nice affordable cut that can be quite flavorful when prepared/sliced properly pic.twitter.com/SYqo47nGNA

— Jake (@TheDustmite) June 29, 2021

Why is my grilled steak tough?

Grilled steak could be tough if it was overcooked. For medium, the internal temperature of the beef when removed from heat should be 145° F. But if it was cooked at too low of a temperature, which requires a longer cooking time, it could also result in a tough steak.

Steaks such as filet mignon, ribeye, or New York Strips naturally lend themselves to being grilled at a high temperature for as short a period of time as needed to get to the right internal temperature.

I set my Traeger pellet grill to the max when doing steak (500° F in my case). But even higher than that is OK too.

If I only set my grill to 350° F, a filet mignon would take a lot longer to get to medium doneness. And that extra cooking time is likely going to make it tougher and chewier too. Like most things in life, grilling requires some skill.

Also, a good meat thermometer is crucial for helping you make sure the meat gets taken off the grill or stovetop at the right time. Again, I like this one on Amazon, and I use mine all the time.

One of the reasons I like that one is it’s not only for meat and poultry. It works great for candy, deep frying, and pretty much anything you need a quick temp read on. Over 3,400 perfect reviews can’t be wrong!

But ultimately, we need to learn how to buy the right steak and how to prepare and grill it in such a manner that even seasoned pitmasters would be envious.

To help with that, check out Is Prime Steak Worth It? In a recent article, where I examined and taste-tested several types of steak to see if the extra money Prime costs is worth it.

I also explained that despite the differences between Certified Angus USDA, regular USDA Choice, grass-fed, and USDA Prime. But which one tasted best?

Just click the link to read it on my site.

Conclusion

We explored what kind of steak isn’t chewy and how to cook steak that is not chewy.

But we also found out whether steak gets more tender the longer it is cooked. And we concluded by looking at whether steak gets tender if it is boiled and why grilled steak could be tough.