Skip to Content

11 Best Porcini Mushroom Substitutes (dried and fresh)

Porcini mushrooms are a culinary delight, but sometimes they may be hard to find or a bit pricey. So what is the porcini mushroom substitute?

The best porcini mushroom substitutes include:

  1. Cremini Mushrooms: Cremini mushrooms, also known as baby bella mushrooms, have a similar earthy flavor and meaty texture to porcini mushrooms. They can be a suitable substitute in many recipes.
  2. Shiitake Mushrooms: Shiitake mushrooms offer a rich umami flavor and a slightly meaty texture, making them a good substitute for porcini mushrooms, especially in Asian-inspired dishes.
  3. Portobello Mushrooms: Portobello mushrooms have a robust flavor and a firm texture, making them a viable substitute for porcini mushrooms in dishes like risottos, stews, and grilled preparations.
  4. Oyster Mushrooms: Oyster mushrooms have a delicate flavor and a tender texture. While not as intense as porcini mushrooms, they can still provide a pleasant mushroom taste in soups, stir-fries, and pasta dishes.
  5. Chanterelle Mushrooms: Chanterelle mushrooms have a mild and fruity flavor with a slightly peppery note. While they differ from porcini mushrooms, they can add a delightful touch to many recipes, including sauces and risottos.

But those aren’t the only options!

Fear not, fellow foodies! In this blog post, we explore nine amazing porcini mushroom substitute options that will bring that earthy, savory goodness to your dishes without breaking the bank or sacrificing flavor.

Ready to embark on a delicious journey? Let’s dive in!

Short Summary

  • Discover delicious porcini mushroom substitutes like shiitake, portobello, and cremini mushrooms!
  • Experience the earthy flavor of dried truffles or herbs & spices for an amazing taste!
  • Try zucchini, corn & green peas to experience a similar texture with added health benefits.

Why Substitute Porcini Mushrooms?

Porcini mushrooms are a prized ingredient in many dishes, but there are times when you might need to find a substitute. Reasons to substitute porcini mushrooms can be thrilling, including availability, cost, personal preference, or dietary restrictions. But don’t worry, we’ve got you covered with a fantastic list of porcini mushroom substitutes that will help you find the perfect alternative to achieve similar flavors and textures in your dishes.

Get ready to explore a world of flavor with exciting alternatives such as shiitake mushrooms, portobello mushrooms, cremini mushrooms, oyster mushrooms, delicious dried mushroom options, luxurious dried truffles, aromatic herbs and spices, and flavorful vegetables with similar taste profiles to porcini mushrooms.

Shiitake mushrooms, in particular, are one of the best substitutes for porcini mushrooms. So, let’s start our flavor adventure!

So now let’s review the . . . 

11 Best Porcini Mushroom Substitutes (dried and fresh)

1. Shiitake Mushrooms: A Top Choice

Shiitake mushrooms take the top spot as an excellent substitute for porcini mushrooms due to their similar earthy, nutty flavor, and meaty texture. These delectable fungi are not only delicious but also more affordable and easier to find in most grocery stores compared to porcini mushrooms. Talk about a win-win situation!

Feel free to use shiitake mushrooms to replace porcini mushrooms in any recipe, as they can be substituted at equal ratios. Imagine the delightful dishes you can create with this versatile and scrumptious substitute!

2. Portobello Mushrooms: Meaty and Flavorful

Another great option to substitute for porcini mushrooms is the meaty and delicious portobello mushroom. With its light umami flavor and similar meaty texture, portobello mushrooms make a great substitute in various dishes, including risotto, soups, and stews.

Easily found in most grocery stores, portobello mushrooms are a convenient and budget-friendly option for those looking to replace porcini mushrooms. So next time you’re in need of a porcini mushroom substitute, give portobello mushrooms a try and experience their delightful taste and texture.

3. Cremini Mushrooms: Earthy and Nutty

Cremini mushrooms, with their earthy flavor and meaty texture, are another great alternative for porcini mushrooms. Their delicious taste makes them a versatile option that can be used in a variety of dishes, from omelets and salads to casseroles, stews, and sauces.

In addition to their fantastic flavor, cremini mushrooms are also packed with nutrients, making them a healthy and tasty choice. So next time you’re looking for a porcini mushroom substitute, don’t hesitate to reach for cremini mushrooms and enjoy their earthy, nutty goodness.

4. Oyster Mushrooms: Unique and Tasty

Looking for a unique and tasty alternative to porcini mushrooms? Oyster mushrooms might be just what you need! With their distinct appearance, fan-like shape, and velvety texture, oyster mushrooms offer a savory umami flavor that makes them a good substitute for porcini mushrooms in dishes like stir-fries, soups, and sauces.

Not only do oyster mushrooms boast a delicious taste, but they also come at a lower cost compared to porcini mushrooms. So, give oyster mushrooms a try and discover their unique and scrumptious flavor as a porcini mushroom substitute.

5. Dried Mushroom Options

If you’re looking for a substitute for dried porcini mushrooms, there are several dried mushroom options that can provide a similar earthy flavor and texture. Dried shiitake or truffles, for example, are excellent choices that retain all of their medicinal and immune-boosting properties.

They also offer a similar taste and chewy texture. These versatile mushrooms can be used in a variety of dishes, such as soups, stews, and stir-fries, and can also be rehydrated and used in salads or as a topping for pizza.

When using dried mushrooms as a substitute, remember to rehydrate them for a few hours in warm water before incorporating them into your dishes. With their more concentrated flavor, dried mushrooms make a fantastic alternative to porcini mushrooms in various recipes.

6. Dried Truffles

For those looking to add a touch of luxury to their dishes as a substitute for porcini mushrooms, dried truffles are an exquisite choice. These gourmet fungi provide an earthy aroma and mild flavor, making them a fantastic alternative in various dishes.

Dried truffles can be either rehydrated or grated into foods to enjoy their delicious umami flavor. While they may be a bit pricier than other substitutes, such as truffle oil, the indulgent taste of dried truffles is sure to impress your taste buds and elevate your culinary creations.

7. Chantrelle Mushrooms

Chantrelle mushrooms (or any wild mushrooms) can be a great substitute for porcini mushrooms in many recipes.

Although they have a slightly different flavor profile, with a mild and fruity taste, they can still add a delightful mushroom essence to dishes. Chantrelles have a delicate and tender texture, making them perfect for sautés, sauces, and risottos. Their subtle peppery note brings a unique twist to the dish.

While they may not have the same intense flavor as porcini mushrooms, Chantrelles provide their own distinct charm and can be a delicious alternative in recipes where porcini mushrooms are called for.

8. Enoki Mushrooms

Enoki mushrooms can be a suitable substitute for porcini mushrooms in certain recipes.

Although they have a different taste and texture, enoki mushrooms can still add a delightfully earthy flavor to dishes that call for porcini mushrooms. They have a delicate and crisp texture with long, thin stems that make them ideal for stir-fries, soups, and salads.

Keep in mind that the flavor profile of enoki mushrooms is not as robust as porcini mushrooms, so you may need to adjust the seasonings accordingly. Nevertheless, enoki mushrooms can provide a tasty alternative when porcini mushrooms are not available.

9. Maitake Mushrooms

Maitake mushrooms can be a flavorful substitute for porcini mushrooms in various dishes.

They have a unique and robust flavor that adds depth to recipes. While the texture of maitake mushrooms is slightly different from porcini mushrooms, they can still be used in similar ways. Maitake mushrooms work well in stir-fries, pasta dishes, risottos, and even as a topping for pizzas.

They have a meaty texture and a rich, earthy taste that can enhance the overall flavor of your dish. So, if you can’t find porcini mushrooms, consider using maitake mushrooms to bring a similar umami-packed punch to your culinary creations.

10. White Button Mushrooms

White button mushrooms can serve as a decent substitute for porcini mushrooms in certain recipes.

While they have a milder flavor compared to porcini mushrooms, they can still add a nice earthy taste to dishes. White button mushrooms work well in soups, stews, sauces, and sautés. They have a versatile nature that allows them to blend nicely with other ingredients.

Keep in mind that the texture of white button mushrooms is different, as they are firmer and less meaty than porcini mushrooms. Nevertheless, they can still contribute to the overall taste and provide a satisfying mushroom flavor to your meals.

Personally, if I was using white mushrooms as a substitute for porcini mushrooms, I would probably finish the dish with a drizzle of truffle oil to impart some of the earthiness that white mushrooms will lack.

11. Brown Cap Mushrooms

Brown caps can be a suitable substitute for porcini mushrooms in many dishes.

They have a rich and earthy flavor that can complement various recipes. Brown cap mushrooms work well in soups, sauces, risotto, and pasta dishes, adding depth and complexity to the flavors. While their texture may be slightly different from porcini mushrooms, they can still provide a satisfying bite.

These mushrooms are readily available and more affordable, making them a convenient option when porcini mushrooms are not accessible. Experiment with brown cap mushrooms to discover new and delicious ways to enhance your favorite dishes.

Tips for Choosing the Right Substitute for Porcini Mushrooms

When selecting a porcini mushroom substitute, it’s essential to consider factors like availability, cost, and personal preferences. Keep in mind the flavor and texture of the dish you’re making, and choose a substitute that complements those characteristics. For instance, dried mushrooms will provide a more intense flavor, while fresh mushrooms will provide a more subtle taste.

Don’t be afraid to experiment with different options to find the perfect match for your recipe. By exploring various substitutes, you may even discover new favorites or unique flavor combinations that elevate your dishes to new heights.

Do Dried Porcini Mushrooms Taste Different from Fresh?

When it comes to dried porcini mushrooms, there’s a little secret: their flavor is actually more intense and concentrated compared to their fresh counterparts! This means that both fresh and dried porcini mushrooms can be used interchangeably in recipes with just a few slight adjustments.

So whether you’re working with fresh porcini mushrooms or dried porcini mushrooms, you can still achieve that rich, earthy taste you’re craving in your dishes, even with the addition of dried thyme and tomato paste. To find porcini mushrooms, make sure to visit your local specialty store or look for them online.

Best Herbs and Spices to Add Earthiness Similar to Porcini Mushrooms

If you’re looking to mimic the earthy flavor of porcini mushrooms in your recipes, certain herbs and spices can be your secret weapon. Thyme, rosemary, cumin, and paprika, for example, can all help to achieve a similar taste and add depth to your dishes.

Don’t be afraid to experiment with different combinations of herbs and spices to find the perfect balance that complements the other ingredients in your recipes. With a little culinary creativity, you can capture the essence of porcini mushrooms and bring their earthy goodness to every bite.


In conclusion, there are numerous porcini mushroom substitutes available to suit your needs and preferences.

From shiitake and portobello mushrooms to dried truffles and herbs, these alternatives offer delicious flavors and textures that can enhance your culinary creations. So, go ahead and experiment with these substitutes and discover the perfect match for your recipes. Happy cooking!

Frequently Asked Questions

Is porcini the same as Portobello?

No, porcini and Portobello mushrooms are not the same. In fact they are radically different.

Porcini mushrooms have a much firmer texture and richer flavor than Portobello mushrooms, making them an excellent choice for creating rich sauces and stews.

So, if you’re looking for a delicious umami flavor in your cooking, go for porcini!

Can I substitute chanterelle for porcini?

Absolutely! Chanterelles are an excellent replacement for porcini mushrooms and you can substitute them one-for-one. The flavor is slightly different but still offers a satisfying earthiness that will make your dish really stand out.

What do porcini mushrooms taste like?

Experience the earthy, savory-sweet flavor of porcini mushrooms for yourself! These mushrooms are delicate in flavor yet strong in body, offering a pleasant mix of woodsy notes and nutty undertones.

Perfect for enhancing stews, sautéed vegetables, and even grilled steak.

Check out all my ingredient substitution articles:

15 Best Substitutes for Achiote Paste & Powder

9 Best Agar Agar Substitutes

15 Best White Balsamic Vinegar Substitutes

9 Simple Madras Curry Powder Substitutes

15 Best Browning Sauce Substitutes

13 Best Substitutes for Mustard Seed

15 Fool-Proof Lyle’s Golden Syrup Substitute Options

Can I Substitute Maple Syrup for Honey?

Hoisin Sauce vs. Oyster Sauce (Difference & Best Substitutes)

19 Best Substitutes for Potato Starch (and when to use them)

21 Best Paneer Substitutes (for your Indian recipes)

21 Best Turmeric Substitutes (you probably have on hand)

Kaffir Lime Leaves vs Lime Leaves: Differences & Substitutes

11 Best Porcini Mushroom Substitutes (dried and fresh)

13 Top Substitutes for Nutritional Yeast (Simple Options)

Jeff Campbell